---
title: "17 November 2026 – ELRC1134-25/26EC"
description: "Case Number: ELRC1134-25/26EC Commissioner: Ncumisa Bantwini Date of Ruling: 17 November 2026 In the matter between NAPTOSA obo Phakama Portia Kedama-Mase (Union/Applicant) And Department of Education-Eastern Cape (Respondent/Employer) `DETAILS OF HEARING AND REPRESENTATION` 1. This arbitration was partly-heard on 19…"
url: "https://elrc.org.za/docs/17-november-2026-elrc1134-25-26ec/"
updated: "2026-11-17"
category: AWARDS
---

# 17 November 2026 – ELRC1134-25/26EC

Case Number: ELRC1134-25/26EC
Commissioner: Ncumisa Bantwini
Date of Ruling: 17 November 2026

In the matter between

NAPTOSA obo Phakama Portia Kedama-Mase
(Union/Applicant)

And

Department of Education-Eastern Cape
(Respondent/Employer)

`DETAILS OF HEARING AND REPRESENTATION`

1. This arbitration was partly-heard on 19 March 2026, 14 April 2026, 04 August 2026, 22 September 2026 and was finalized on 21 October 2026 in the offices of the respondent in Stutterheim. It came before the ELRC in terms of Section 191 (1) 191 (5) (a) of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 as amended, (the LRA). Both parties handed in bundle of documents in support of their cases. The applicant’s bundle was labelled as bundle A and the respondent’s bundle was labelled as bundle B. Services of English/Xhosa interpreter was utilized.
2. Parties were allowed to submit written closing arguments on 28 October 2026. All arguments have been considered in the preparation of this award. The proceedings were digitally and manually recorded.
3. Mr. Aaron Mhlontlo an official from NAPTOSA appeared for the applicant while Mr. Xolani Sam appeared for the respondent, the Department of Education-Eastern Cape. `ISSUE TO BE DECIDED`
4. I am required to decide whether the dismissal of the applicant was substantively fair or not. I have considered all the evidence and arguments, but because section 138 (7) of the Labour Relations Act, 66 of 1995, as amended requires brief reasons. I have only referred to the evidence and arguments that I regard as necessary to substantiate my findings and determination of the dispute. `BACKGROUND TO THE DISPUTE`
5. The applicant was employed by the respondent on 10 May 2021 as an Educator Post Level 1. She was dismissed on 19 January 2026, and was earning R362 103.00 per annum at the time of dismissal.
6. The applicant was charged with the following allegations:
   “ Charge 1
   • It is alleged that you committed an act of misconduct in terms of section 17 (1) (d) of the Employment of Educator’s Act 76 0f 1998 as amended which inter alia reads as follows: An educator commits misconduct if she seriously assaults with intention to cause grievous bodily harm to another employee “In that you Ms. Kedama-Mase while on duty assaulted Ms. Radebe (another employee) on 25 July 2022.
   Charge 2
   • It is alleged that you committed an act of misconduct in terms of section 18 (1) (j) of the Employment of Educators Act 76 of 1998 as amended which inter alia reads as follows: an educator commits misconduct if she absents herself from work without a valid reason or permission from the employer” in that: you Ms Kedama-Mase absented yourself from work during the period 23 February 2022 to 23 September 2022 which totaled to 85 days.
   Charge 3
   • It is alleged that you committed an act of misconduct in terms of 18 (1) (f) of the Employment of Educators Act 78 of 1998 as amended with inter alia reads as follows: an educator commits misconduct if she unjustifiable prejudiced the administration, discipline or efficiency of the department of education or school” in that you Ms. Kedama-Mase on the 02 February 2023 while on duty during the staff meeting you demonstrated an abusive or insolent behavior by swearing at Ms. Kene Infront of staff members and the school principal”.
7. The applicant was found guilty of the charges and was subsequently dismissed. She seeks retrospective reinstatement as a remedy.

SURVEY OF EVIDENCE

```
               The respondent’s evidence
```

1. In his opening statement, Mr. Sam submitted that the applicant was charged for misconduct and was found guilty of the charges. The respondent will use oral and documentary evidence to prove that the chairperson arrived at the correct decision. There is a breakdown of employee-employer relationship.
2. Ms. Yonela Radebe, the first witness for the respondent testified as follows:
3. She works for the respondent as an Educator, post level 1 and she knows the applicant as a former colleague at Cathcart High School. With regards to the assault allegations, they were invited to a workshop to be held at Stutterheim High School. It was herself and the applicant who were supposed to attend the workshop. After the morning briefing around 08h00 the bus was already waiting in the parking lot.
4. She got in the bus and informed the driver that the employee is in the list and they should wait until 08h15. After leaving the school, in less than a kilometer, Reo, the fleet manager phoned them requesting them to go back and fetch the applicant and the driver turned back. She was seated at the front and the applicant opened the back door of the sprinter bus to have a sit at the back They took off to Stutterheim and few meters later, the applicant said she is feeling cold and the driver said he had just switched on the heater.
5. The applicant said to the driver ‘Melikhaya, I want to sit at the front you must stop the bus”. Melikaya stopped the bus and the applicant came to the front door. She moved to allow the applicant a space for her to sit. Front seat accommodates 3 people. She (the witness) was seated next to the door at the front. When the applicant came in she said shift, I want to come in, she (the witness) said I am shifting backward so that you can go pass, I am not shifting. She stepped on the bus and climbed on the floor and put her bag next to her on the other side. The applicant put something on the dashboard and stepped at the back of the bus again. She stepped out again and said, “I want to come in” Melikaya said “you have been given a space, you can come in”.
6. The applicant climbed inside again and pointed at her (witness) face saying, “you are taking me for a ride, you are not doing this for the first time”. She (the applicant) was angry and she (the witness) moved her head while moving the hand as she was not expecting that the applicant would now fight, feeling intimidated and uncomfortable. She (the applicant) slapped at her and she (the witness) bite her finger when she also decided to step out of the bus as well and they started fighting and it was self-defense to her.

1. Melikaya stopped the fight and she stepped inside the bus again throwing the applicant’s bags outside to her. The bus drove back to school and the driver went to the Principal. The driver drove to hospital as she was stained with blood as the finger was bleeding. She had some stiches in the finger, she went to her residence to change and went to Mrs. Hart, the Principal to report the incident.
2. The Deputy Principal advised her not to attend the workshop. Upon entering thePprincipal’s office, she said “did she moor you” saying that is what the applicant told her when she came to her office. Messes Hart and Radebe sat her down asking as to what happened and she relayed the story. She then went to the police station to wrote a statement and she also got J88 form. On 26 July 2022, she was called by the police advising that a common assault case has been opened against her. The police suggested that they both agree to drop charges and they did that at the Magistrates court.
3. Under cross-examination, the witness testified as follows:
4. She went to the Principal’s office the day before the workshop to remind her. Her statement appears on page 6; and the incident occurred in 2022 which is long time ago hence she does not recall the actual dates. She did not know why the Principal did not record that she went to her office in the letter. She was told not to go into detail of what transpired in her statement. She threw the applicant’s bags out of the bus and it is not true that there was a laptop in the bag, the applicant was never given a laptop by the DOE.
5. When it was put to the witness that she omitted a lot of things in the statement because she wanted to appear as a good person and the applicant to be painted as a bad person, her response was, that is not true. She was present when J88 was completed by the doctor. The witness stated that there is a missing page when a question as to why there is nothing written about the finger and the wound (pages 7 and 8).
6. When reference was made to Mr. Dyonas’s statement which states that Ms. Radebe pushed Ms. Kedama-Mase, her response was that she does not agree with that part as she did not push the applicant. She was comfortable sitting next to the door but the applicant said “phuma ndingene”, meaning, “get out I want to get inside”. She wanted the applicant to sit in the middle of her and the driver but she never specified where she wanted to sit.

1. When it was put to the witness that the applicant will testify that when she wanted to step inside the bus, she stood Infront of her (the witness) at the side step of the bus, while she was standing there, she (the witness) started swearing at her and pushed her (the applicant) she fell down and she (the witness) jumped off the bus to fight with her. She then took her bags, her response was, that is not true.
2. Under re-examination, the witness stated that she was requested by Mrs. Hart to write a statement and she must have sent it on the following day (26/07/2022) as she was called at the police station. She submitted all the pages of J88 form. She is not the one who became violent to the applicant. She made a summary of what happened. Her finger was bitten and that appears in her statement.
3. The second witness Ms. Nyameka Kene testified as follows:
4. She is testifying on charge 2. She is in charge of the attendance register and would take all leave forms to the Principal, Ms. Hart who has since retired. The applicant absented herself for 85 days between 23 February 2022 to 23 September 2022. Pages 13 to 39 reflect attendance registers reflecting the applicant’s days of absence. A line is drawn on pages 13,15,19, 29, where the applicant was absent. Employees are entitled to 36 days for a cycle of 3 years. Pages 54 to 88 contain leave application forms in respect of sick leave and there are sick leave certificates attached. Where there is no approval by Mrs. Hart, it means the leave forms are not authentic.
5. Under cross-examination, the witness testified as follows:
6. She is in charge of the attendance register and she is currently delegated by the Principal as she is the curriculum head in the school. In 2009 she became a Principal but she was never given a delegation letter to perform leave management duties. In terms of DOE regulations, something in writing would be a proof. The witness did not respond when it was put to her that the school Principal is the only person to manage the attendance register and that there is no space for a Deputy Principal to sign. She did not bring the control book with her. The leave forms on pages 54 and 55 were approved. Pages 59 to 81 reflects medical certificates and this means the reason for absence was valid, the Principal has appended her signature.
7. Pages 11 and 12 of bundle B were not captured and it was the Admin Clerk’s responsibility to capture staff leave. Page 85 and 86 reflects the chats between the applicant and the Principal. The applicant submitted leave from February 2022 to March 2022. The applicant’s absence of 4 days was accounted for as reflected in pages 54 to 81. This means that she was wrongly charged as she absented herself for valid reasons. The communication reflected on page 89 is from Ms. Ncombo who was the Circuit Manager. The applicant decided to escalate her issue to her. The witness stated that no one was jealous of the applicant when it was put to her that the applicant was treated badly by the management of the school and they were jealous of her.

1. Under re-examination, the witness stated that she does not know the number that is reflected on page 89, nothing confirms ill treatment of the applicant. There are no numbers in the WhatsApp group chats (pages 84 to 85). The Principal recommends or does not recommend the leave.
2. With regards to charge 3, Ms. Kene testified that she is the Deputy Principal and the curriculum head at the school and one of the responsibilities is to make sure that teaching takes place in a conducive environment and that timetable is done and is followed by teachers. In the mornings, they (educators) first go to the staff room for a briefing meeting. The Principal tells them what is going to happen at the school.
3. They had 2-time tables because the applicant was not reporting at school. The one timetable had the applicant and the one without the applicant scheduled for classes. On this day they used a timetable without the applicant and she arrived. The Principal told teachers that they will use the time table with the applicant. She followed the Principal to her office to ask if she can call teachers to the staff room as some teachers had already left when the applicant arrived at school and she agreed.
4. While she was standing next to the door at the staff room after the announcement, she told the applicant that she called other teachers, and she said” I am going to come in, I have been waiting for this day, you are old 51 years, but “uvalele abantwana” you are blocking the youth from getting positions. The applicant was angry and was provoking her to say something. Teachers were already inside the staff room and she pushed the door coming inside. Ms. Ceshemba said “you are rude and silly”, and asked the applicant to go to the Principal’s office. The applicant was shouting all the way. She told the Principal that she was not afraid of Ms. Kene, she can moor her. She (the witness) then went to the police station to get an interdict. The Principal advised her to write a report to the Circuit Manager but she did not do that because she did not want to escalate the issue. The purpose of the meeting was to advise teachers to continue with the time table with no PKM. This was creating confusion to the kids and disadvantaging them.
5. Under cross-examination, the witness testified as follows:
6. On 02 February 2023, the applicant came in while teachers were going out of the briefing session which starts at 07h15-07h20. She understands that there is no provision of a briefing meeting in the DOE policy and it is not mandatory. The morning briefing is an internal arrangement of the school to manage and control teaching. The policy was drafted in 2009 but she did not bring it and it was never reviewed. The applicant swore at her in the passage while she (the witness) was standing next to the door, other teachers were inside the staff room (Messrs. Ceshemba, Gqomfa and Radebe) and others were coming down the stairs, they heard what the applicant was saying.

1. Aunty who was cleaning heard the applicant but she cannot recall the names of the 2 other teachers. She called grade 8-12 teachers and the Principal was in her office. The Principal said she will report the issue to Mr. Mncono, her supervisor but she does not have proof. The witness did not comment when it was put to her the incident was not reported because it never happened. There was no school logbook, no minutes of the meeting to prove that the incident took place.
2. Copies of the 2-time tables were not submitted by the witness. A copy of an attendance register/minutes were not submitted by the witness to prove there was a meeting on 02 February 2022. With regards to insolent behavior, she did not make a follow up with the Principal and she does not know if the applicant was issued with a warning or not by the Principal.
3. Under re-examination, the witness stated that briefing sessions are to make every teacher of what is going to happen, there were no minutes for 02 February 2022 and there is no reason to accuse the applicant with the charges. The applicant was shouting while going to the Principal’s office and she asked her to leave. The admin clerk, Fiona, Radebe and Gqeba were present.
4. The 3rd witness Mrs. Nokulunga Sikiti testified as follows:
5. She was the chairperson of the disciplinary hearing which led to the dismissal of the applicant. She was using a different car and the respondent’s representative was using his own car. They were booked in the same hotel and were not sharing accommodation nor lunch with him. She has been chairing disciplinary hearings for over 20 years while she was still employed by the respondent and she has never been challenged for unacceptable conduct.
6. Ms. Radebe who had assault allegation was called to testify. The driver was also called to testify. The applicant disputed the evidence of the 2 witnesses. Page 10 reflects the applicant’s SASAMS report from 10 /01/ 2022 to 09 /06 /2023 (page 10 bundle B). The employee was advised to come back to work or her absence will be regarded as leave without pay. She was also given an option of applying for incapacity leave. The initial findings of 3 months suspension without pay were an error and she explained the error to the HOD. The sanction she issued was dismissal of the applicant (pages 12 to 33 bundle A).
7. Under cross-examination, the witness testified as follows:
8. She requested the district office to assist in sharing documents relating to the applicant’s sick leave record as parties did not have the same or similar documents in relation to the leave. It transpired that the applicant had exhausted her sick leave and was advised by the Principal (page 55 bundle B). When an employee is sick, it is a valid reason if there are supporting documents. The charge does not have any sentence relating to supporting documents. The SASAMS report does not contain information about documents. An employee can report sick without submitting a sick certificate. Pages 54 to 89 contains leave forms with sick certificates attached to them.
9. The witness was referred to a list of staff members who did not submit sick certificates to substantiate their absence (pages 87 and 88 bundle A), and only the applicant submitted. Her response was that she only dealt with the applicant’s issue and that she had no knowledge of other employees. The witness did not respond when it was put to her that she was inconsistent in finding the applicant guilty of this allegation as she disregarded the evidence about other employees who did not even submit the sick certificates to the school Principal. Ms. Kene testified only on the sick leave forms which were submitted to her. She said she never saw some of them but she never said they were incorrect (pages 58 to 80). She is not aware that Ms Kene’s evidence was not corroborated.

1. With regards to charge 1, the witness was referred to J88 in respect Ms. Radebe wherein no injuries are indicated to prove that she was assaulted. The witnesses’ response was that Ms. Radebe and Mr. Dyonase testified that the applicant assaulted Ms. Radebe (page 7 to 8 of bundle B). Pages 51 and 52 reflects clinical findings that Ms. Radebe assaulted the applicant, and Ms. Jonas testified that both Ms. Radebe and the applicant were fighting and the applicant started the fighting. The charge does not talk to fighting but with assault. The employee was seriously hurt/inured by Ms. Radebe.
2. With regards to charge 3, the meeting did not start because of the applicant’s disruption. The applicant was not a baseline Educator, but went to the meeting, she was barred from getting inside the office by Ms. Kene. She is not aware that Misses Kene and Radebe’s evidence was not corroborated.
3. Under re-examination, the witness stated that she took a decision based on the letter from HRSASAMS relating to the applicant’s leave. There was no audited statement about leave from HR. There was no evidence led about the list of other staff members who absented themselves without submitting sick leave (page 86 to 88 bundle B). She considered all the evidence led by both parties before issuing a sanction of dismissal of the applicant.
4. In closing, Mr. Sam argued that the employee led evidence because the applicant pleaded not guilty to all the charges. Under cross examination, Ms. Radebe testified that there are missing pages of her J88 form indicating injuries sustained.
5. With regards to charge 2, Ms. Kene testified that the leave forms which were submitted by the applicant were not leave forms that are completed by Educators but are leave forms that are applicable to PSA administrative staff. The applicant denied all the charges levelled against her. The respondent’s representative finally argued that the applicant’s dismissal was both procedurally and substantively fair and that her case must be dismissed. `The applicant’s case`
6. According to Mr. Mhlontlo ’s opening statement, the applicant is challenging the substantive unfairness of the applicant’s dismissal. The chairperson was biased towards the respondent; she shared lunch and was being driven to and from the venue by the respondent’s representative. There were documents which were not disclosed until the finalization of the disciplinary hearing. According to the chairperson’s findings the sanction was 3 months suspension without pay. The chairperson changed the sanction to dismissal without informing the applicant.
7. With regards to substantive issues, the applicant did not assault another employee, she is the one who was assaulted. She never absented herself without a reason, leave forms were submitted. The employee never disrupted staff meeting as there was never a staff meeting, no minutes of the meeting were produced by the employer. Dismissal was not an appropriate sanction as the alleged offences were not serious. The applicant seeks retrospective reinstatement as a remedy.
8. Ms. Portia Pakama Kedama-Mase, the applicant testified as follows:
9. She works for the respondent at JJ Special School in Queenstown since December 2025. She requested a transfer from Cathcart High School and it was approved.
10. With regards to charge 1, she was teaching at Cathcart High School with Ms. Radebe and they were scheduled to attend a workshop at Stutterheim when the incident occurred. It is not true that she assaulted Ms. Radebe, instead she was assaulted by her. Upon her arrival at the school around 08h05 on 25 July 2022 at the school she went to the Principal’s office who phoned the driver of the mini bus to come to fetch her (the applicant) and he did. After boarding the bus, the driver left, she felt cold and requested the driver to find a space for her at the front.

1. The driver stopped the bus and she requested Ms. Radebe to shift to the middle seat or jump outside so that she can sit on the middle front seat but she (Ms. Radebe) refused. They were shocked by her response and the driver requested her again and she refused. She (the applicant) was carrying a laptop and handbag, and while she was trying to go to the middle seat, it was difficult because of the space and the attire she was wearing. While she was still negotiating with Ms. Radebe to move, she (Ms. Radebe) pushed her hand saying “get away” she fell on the ground. Ms. Radebe punched her scratching her face and pulling her jacket saying “I am not scared of you” I am Zulu and I am not scared of Xhosas. When she fell off the bus, she sustained a cut on the left leg. The driver came to separate them as they were fighting. Ms. Radebe threw his laptop bag and handbag outside. She (the applicant) picked them up and sat at the back. The driver drove back to school and she went straight to the Principal’s office to report the incident and she was advised to go to the doctor. Her husband advised her to also go to the police to lay a charge and she did.
2. Reference was made to the driver’s statement wherein Portia said, “UPortia wathi ku Miss Radebe ucela abhekele wathi u Miss Radebe akafuni akazuhlala esphakathini yena uright kulendawo akuyo” {Portia requested Miss Radebe to shift and Miss Radebe refused saying she does not want to sit in the middle she is fine with where she is seated page 54 bundle B). She was given J88 form at the police station and she was examined by the doctor. Ms. Radebe’s J88 form shows that she was normal with no signs of injuries indicated (page 7 to 9 bundle B).
3. With her J88 form, the clinical findings indicate that she sustained bruised left elbow, sprained left ankle with lacerations, swollen lower lip and left side of the face with scratches in her chest (pages 49 to 53 bundle A). These medical findings mean that she is the one who was assaulted, injured and attacked by Ms. Radebe. She is disputing that she assaulted Ms. Radebe.
4. With regards to charge 2, she never absented herself without a valid reason or permission from the employer during period 23 February 2022 to 23 September 2022. The reason for her absence was that she was sick and she submitted sick certificates as proof. The applicant made reference to the following sick certificates with duly completed leave forms as well as annual leave forms; pages 50, 67,69,74,78,79,81,82 and 85. All the sick certificates/leave forms were submitted to Wendy who is the Principal’s clerk as it is the procedure she was aware of.
5. The applicant testified further that the list that appears from pages 86 to 88 of bundle B are Cathcart High School staff members who had submitted and those who had not submitted their sick leave certificates. The names with ticks next to them are those who submitted the leave and sick leave certificates and forms. There are ticks next to the applicant’s name in all the pages and this means that she (the applicant) submitted all the annual leave and sick leave documents. The names of the staff members who do not have ticks next to their names are as follows; Page 86 Theron Wit, Theron Wit, Wanana N, Human, Lamani, Soraqa, Makalima, Makalima, Kirly, Naidoo, Van Schalwyk, Ceshemba, Caron B, Caron P, Caron Z, Odendaal, Owusu, and Thomas.
6. On page 87 the list is as follows; Han, Nikani, Parlozi, Soraqa, Theron B, Makalima, Maki, Theron Z. Maki J, Mzwanana, Theron Z, Human and Lamani.
7. On page 88 the list is as follows; Sibi, Lamani, Pongolo, Soraqa, Ceshemba P.P, Makalima, Odendaal, Pongolo, Gqola, Makalima, Human, Palozi, Soraqa, Theron B, Geldeman, Makalima, and Nobaza.
8. The applicant disputed charge 3 submitting that there was no meeting, she narrated the issue indicating that educators received a call from the intercom to go to the staff room. Upon entering the staff room Ms. Kene was standing at the door telling her that she was not allowed inside. Some few teachers were inside. The principal was in her office.
9. The applicant disputed demonstrating an abusive or insolent behavior and swearing at Ms. Kene. The applicant stated further that there was no meeting on 02 February 2025. There was no attendance register nor minutes to prove that there was a meeting. She seeks retrospective reinstatement to her former position with effect from 19 March 2026 at JJ Serfontein/Gali Thembani Special School.
10. Under cross-examination, the applicant testified as follows:
11. He was aware about the training that was scheduled for 09h00 in Stutterheim. She arrived around 07h55 and the bus had already left the school. The driver was called to come and fetch her and upon boarding the bus after few meters she requested the driver to stop as she was feeling cold and wanted to sit at the front.
12. Ms. Radebe was sitting next to the door hence she requested her to jump outside so that she can come in and sit in the middle. Ms. Radebe refused to move out and her attire did not allow her to move to the middle while Ms Radebe was still in the first seat in the front. She did not make a space for her to go pass and this is confirmed by the driver’s statement.
13. The injuries she sustained were bruised left elbow, sprained left ankle with lacerations, swollen lower lip and left side of the face with scratches in her chest (pages 49 to 53 bundle A). She first went to the police station and she was advised to consult with the doctor and she did. She was staying in Queenstown hence she decided to go to Dr Zaula whose surgery is in Queenstown.
14. With regards to charge 2, the school Principal approves the leave for staff. Pages 54 to 71 of bundle A are the sick leave forms are approved by the Principal. She kept the forms for her records after she submitted to the Clerk for the Principal’s attention. It is not her duty to check if the Principal captured the leave previously submitted. When a question as to why was Ms Kene not aware about the above sick leave forms was posed, her response was that leave forms were submitted to the Principal and or school Clerk.
15. The school Clerk used to make follow-ups if staff members have not submitted their sick leaves. She made reference of the list that is contained from pages 86 to 88 of bundle B. According to the list, there are ticks next to her name and this means that she submitted all the sick certificates.
16. The applicant disputed having received the letter advising her that she has exhausted the sick leave days and her leave falls under incapacity leave category (page 55 of bundle B). The letter does not have a signature acknowledging receipt. The author of the letter is N.G. Hart, the Principal and not Ms Kene. The principal did not testify in these proceedings.
17. The applicant testified with regards to charge 3 that there was no meeting on 02 February 2023. As an educator in the school, she is allowed to go anywhere in the school premises, If there was a meeting, she was supposed to be allowed to attend. No minutes nor attendance register was produced to prove that there was a meeting.
18. When she got to the staff room, Ms Kene blocked her way and she reported the treatment she was getting to the Principal. She disputed demonstrating an abusive/insolent behavior by swearing at Ms Kene in front of staff members and the school Principal. No video footage nor witness was called to corroborate Ms Kene’s evidence.
19. Under re-examination, the applicant stated that she was charged in respect of 23 February 2022 to 23 September 2022 in respect of charge 2. The letter on page 55 was issued on 26 October 2023 and talks to sick leave up to 26 October 2022. There is no proof of service of the letter dated 26 October 2022 and she never received it. The charge does not say anything about being absent without approval. She never absented herself without a reason as she was sick. She submitted medical certificates to validate the reason for her absence.
20. The clerk, of the school, Wendy was responsible for submitting or making submissions to HRSASAMS where all leave is captured and audited (pages 11 to 12 of bundle B). The applicant disputed charge 3 as she never demonstrated an abusive or insolent behavior by swearing at Ms. Kene. There was no meeting in the staff room on 02 February 2022.
21. In respect of charge 1, the applicant disputed grievously assaulting Ms. Radebe, instead she is the one who was assaulted by Ms Radebe. She made comparison of her J88 form and that of Ms. Radebe and stated that under general examination,on Ms. Radebe’s form, the doctor wrote that everything is normal while hers the doctor indicates that she sustained injuries like bruised left elbow, sprained left ankle with lacerations, swollen lower lip and left side of the face with scratches in her chest (pages 49 to 53 bundle A and pages 7 to 8 of bundle B). Ms. Radebe pushed her and she fell outside the bus when she was standing pleading with her to let her go to the middle seat of the bus. The statement of the driver confirms that pushing someone is assault.
22. The 3rd respondent’s witness confirmed that she was accommodated in the same lodge with the respondent’s representative, and she sent the respondent’s representative to buy her lunch, they met at the breakfast and they were interacting. She seeks retrospective reinstatement at JJ Serfontein/Dalithemba Special School.
23. In closing, Mr. Mhlontlo argued as follows:
24. The applicant is aware of the respondent’s rules as well as its consistent application of the rules. The respondent did not suffer harm or loss and as such it failed to discharge the onus of showing the fairness of the applicant’s dismissal.
25. On charge 2, the 3rd respondent’s witness testified that there were some outstanding documents and information and that she got stuck in reaching an informed and wise decision. She relied on information which she received from HR section of Amathole West District to provide more information. It is clear that the decision to dismiss the applicant was based on evidence which was never led and interrogated through cross examination.
26. In NUM obo Botsane v Anglo Platinum (Rustenburg Section) 3A 2013/42 [2014] ZALAC 24; (2014) 35 ILJ 2406 (LAC) (handed down on 15 May 2014) the LAC held that the Employer is not permitted to introduce an allegation that had not initially been relied on to justify the dismissal. If a new basis to dismiss is discovered after the dismissal, the Employer should convene a new proceeding to allow the Employee to respond to the new allegation.
27. The accommodation of the chairperson and the respondent’s representative under one roof wherein they had dinner and breakfast in one dining hall was not by accident but by design to ensure that the mission was accomplished. The chairperson’s impartiality was compromised.
28. In relation to charge 1, the person who was assaulted was the applicant and not the 1st witness as alleged. That is evidently demonstrated by J88 forms by the police and doctors (pages 49 to 53 of bundle A and pages 7 to 9 of bundle B).
29. In relation to charge 2, Ms. Kene testified that the applicant absented herself from school without valid reason or permission of the respondent. This allegation was also disputed by the applicant and her evidence was supported by documentary evidence (pages 54 to 85 bundle A).
30. In relation to charge 3, no minutes and attendance register of the meeting could be produced, to prove that there was a meeting on that day. The school Principal was not even called to the meeting to prove that this was a fabricated story. The applicant disputes the allegation of demonstrating an abusive or insolent behavior by swearing at Ms. Kene infront of staff members and the school Principal.
31. The applicant was aware of all the rules relating to the 3 charges preferred against her as they are valid, but she continuously maintained that she did not break the rules.
32. The applicant’s representative argued further that the respondent failed to apply the disciplinary rule consistently as Ms. Radebe was never subjected to the same disciplinary process for seriously assaulting the applicant. This is shown by J88 form which were signed by the police and doctors (pages 49-53) as well as on pages 7 to 9 of bundle B.
33. Pages 86 to 88 of bundle A indicate the list of educators who were absent from school and who could not submit leave forms/sick leave forms however, they were never disciplined by the respondent. Dismissal was not an appropriate sanction and the applicant has a clean disciplinary record. The applicant seeks retrospective reinstatement at JJ Serfontein/Gali Thembani Special School within the Chris Hani West District as a remedy. `ANALYSIS OF EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENT`
34. In terms of Section 192(2) of the LRA, the onus is on the employer to prove the fairness of the dismissal of the employee. Section 188(2) of the LRA stipulates that dismissal must be for a fair reason and in accordance with a fair procedure.
35. It is common cause that the applicant was charged and subsequently dismissed for 3 allegations of misconduct as stipulated in the charge sheet that appears on pages 2 and 3 of bundle B.
36. In all instances where the sanction of dismissal is imposed, the respondent has a duty to show that the requirements of the Code of Good Practice have been satisfied namely to show;
    • That a work place rule or standard has been contravened;
    • That the rule was a valid or reasonable rule or standard;
    • That the employee was aware or could reasonably have been expected to have been aware of the rule or standard;
    • That the rule or standard has been consistently applied by the employer and;
    • That dismissal was an appropriate sanction for the contravention of the rule or standard.
37. It is common cause the applicant was found guilty of all the charges levelled against her.
38. It is common cause also that the applicant was occupying a position of an Educator Post Level 1 and has been in the respondent’s employ for 4 years.
39. The respondent called 2 witnesses to testify on the 3 charges and none of the witnesses corroborated each other. This means that the respondent relied on the evidence of single witness. Courts have pronounced that the evidence of a single witness should be treated with caution in Siyabonga Ngcobo v The State (115/2024) (2025) [ZASCA 12].
40. In relation to charge 1, if one compares J88 forms of the applicant and that of Ms. Radebe, the applicant is the one who sustained injuries while Ms. Radebe’s form is written normal under general examination. It appears that the applicant is the one who was assaulted by the 1st witness, Ms. Radebe.
41. It must be noted that neither the applicant nor the 1st witness called a witness to corroborate their versions in this charge. The applicant made reference of the drivers’ statement which indicated that the 1st witness is the one who started the fight and threw the applicant’s bags out of the bus.
42. `It is the respondent’s case through Ms. Kene’s evidence in charge 2 that the applicant absented herself from school without valid reason or permission of the respondent. The applicant disputed this allegation and her evidence was supported by documentary evidence (pages 54 to 85 bundle A). The applicant’s reason was that she absented herself from duty because she was sick.`
43. The evidence of the 2nd witness, Ms. Kene in relation to charge 3 was never corroborated by any documentary evidence. None of the witnesses which the witness stated they were in the staff room nor Aunty, the cleaner whom she alleged they saw and heard the applicant swearing at Ms. Kene were called to testify. The Principal was also not called to testify. No video footage, school log book, minutes nor attendance register was produced to prove that there was a meeting and to prove the allegation. It must be noted that the applicant disputed the allegation and also disputed that there was ever a meeting on 02 February 2023.
44. It must be noted that the applicant conceded under cross-examination that she is aware of the rules/policies of the department and that her conduct was not in breach of the respondent’s rule/policies.
45. With regards to inconsistency challenge, I agree with the applicant’s contention to the fact that Ms. Radebe should have been charged for assaulting the applicant.
46. It is also the applicant’s undisputed evidence that pages 86 to 88 of bundle A indicate the list of 40 educators who were absent from school and who could not submit leave forms/sick leave forms however, they were never disciplined by the respondent although they absented themselves from school without submitting any documents to substantiate their absence.
47. In Consani v Engineering (Pty) Ltd v Commission for Conciliation Mediation and Arbitration and Others, (2004) 25 ILJ 1707 (LC), on paragraph 19 the court held as follows: “… An inconsistency challenge will fail where the employer is able to differentiate between employees who have committed similar transgressions on the basis of inter alia differences in personal circumstances, the severity of the misconduct or on the basis of other material factors.”
48. The respondent did not present a plausible reason or justification for the different treatment between the 41 employees and the applicant.
49. In NUM and Another v Amcoal Colliery t/a Amot Colliery and another [2000] 8 BLLR (LAC), in determining the fairness of the dismissal the court said the following:

“The parity principle was designed to prevent unjustified selective punishment or dismissal and to ensure that like cases are treated alike…”.

1. The relationship between the applicant and respondent has not been broken, or was never substantiated that it has.
2. `Schedule 8 item 3 (6) provides;`

“(6) The employer should apply the penalty of dismissal consistently with the way in which it has been applied to the same and other employees in the past, and consistently as between the two or more employees who participate in the misconduct under consideration.”

1. `The applicant has discharged onus to prove that the respondent was induced by improper motives or acted capriciously when other employees were not charged at all for the same misconduct. The respondent had no objective and fair reason for selectively dismissing the applicant while the 41 employees were not dismissed at all. I am saying this bearing in mind that inconsistency is not a rule on its own.`
2. `Section 23 of the Constitution Act 108 of 1996 provides that “Everyone has a right to fair labour Practices”. This right is enjoyed by both the employer and the employee. One of the primary purposes of the Labour Relations Act is to give effect to the fundamental rights conferred by Section 23 of the Constitution. Section 3 of the LRA provides that “Any person applying this Act must interpret its provisions- (a) to give effect to its primary objects, (b) in compliance with the international law obligations of the Republic”.`
3. `In the circumstances, I find that the sanction of dismissal was not an appropriate sanction as the respondent’s conduct amounts to inconsistency.`
4. On the basis of the above evidence, I find that the applicant’s evidence is probable. I therefore find that the dismissal of the applicant was substantively unfair.
5. `In terms of Section 192(2) of the LRA, the onus is on the employer to prove the fairness of the dismissal of the employees. Section 188(2) of the LRA stipulates that dismissal must be for a fair reason and in accordance with a fair procedure. The respondent has failed to discharge its onus to establish the fairness of the applicant’s dismissal.`
6. `I find that dismissal of the applicant was not an appropriate sanction. The Constitutional Court in NEHAWU vs University of Cape Town (2003) CC reiterated the point that the arbitrator has to weigh the interest of both the employer and the employee in coming to a decision whether the dismissal of the employee was fair or not.`
7. `On the basis of the above evidence, I am therefore satisfied that an attempt was made by the respondent in compliance with the provisions of Item 4(2) of Schedule 8 Code of Dismissal: Misconduct. I therefore find the applicant not guilty of the charges levelled against her.`

```
           Relief
```

1. `I order the respondent, The Department of Education Eastern Cape to reinstate the applicant and pay 9 months’ salary as back pay amounting to R271 577.25 calculated as R30 175.25 per month x 9 months’ salary to the applicant, Ms. Portia Pakama Kedama-Mase. The 9 months’ salary ordered is for loss of earnings due to the fact that the employee ‘s dismissal was substantively unfair.`
2. `In all the circumstances of this case and after due consideration of all the facts which by law I must consider, I deem the following award fair and equitable:`

```
AWARD
```

1. `The dismissal of the applicant, Ms. Portia Pakama Kedama-Mase by the Respondent, Department of Education-Eastern Cape was substantively unfair.`
2. The Department of Education-Eastern Cape is ordered to reinstate the applicant, Ms. Portia Pakama Kedama-Mase on conditions of employment not less favorable to that which she enjoyed prior dismissal. The reinstatement is effective from the date of dismissal and the applicant must return to work at JJ Serfontein/Gali Thembani Special School within the Chris Hani West District on 20 November 2026.
3. The respondent is directed and ordered to pay the applicant 9 month’s salary as back pay as follows: An amount of R271 577.25 calculated as R30 175.25 salary per month x 9 months on 20 November 2026 into the applicant’s bank account as per the respondent’s records.

Ncumisa Bantwini
ELRC Arbitrator
