---
title: "17 November 2026 – ELRC58-26/27WC"
description: "Case Number: ELRC58-26/27WC Commissioner: Carlton Johnson Date of Ruling: 16 November 2026 In the MATTER between SAOU OBO C BARON (/Applicant) And WESTERN CAPE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT (Respondent) DETAILS OF HEARING AND REPRESENTATION 1. The arbitration hearing in this matter was…"
url: "https://elrc.org.za/docs/17-november-2026-elrc58-26-27wc/"
updated: "2026-11-18"
category: AWARDS
---

# 17 November 2026 – ELRC58-26/27WC

Case Number: ELRC58-26/27WC
Commissioner: Carlton Johnson
Date of Ruling: 16 November 2026

In the MATTER between

SAOU OBO C BARON
(/Applicant)

And

WESTERN CAPE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
(Respondent)

DETAILS OF HEARING AND REPRESENTATION

1. The arbitration hearing in this matter was heard on 20 October 2026 by virtual platform.
2. The applicant was represented by Illoïs De Goede an official of SAOU, and Abigail Blanckner appeared for the respondent.
3. The proceedings were digitally recorded.
4. The parties agreed to submit written closing arguments by close of business on 27 October 2026. Arguments were received from both parties. The arguments are part of the extensive record in the matter and repetition is not required. I will refer to the salient points in my analysis where necessary.
5. The applicant submitted a bundle marked A consisting of 42 pages. The respondent’s bundle consisted of 2 pages.
   THE ISSUE TO BE DECIDED
6. I must decide whether the applicant is entitled to receive full remuneration as a Post Level 1 Educator for the period 01 January 2026 to 31 March 2026.
   SUMMARY OF EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENTS
   THE APPLICANT’S CASE
7. The applicant argued that she is a suitably qualified educator who can teach in the Foundation Phase. She is therefore regarded as a fully qualified Post Level 1 Educator teaching Grade R. The applicant has been working as a Grade R educator at Steenberg’s Cove Primary Schools since 01 January 2026. The post became vacant from 01 January 2026 after the previous incumbent passed away in October 2025. The school uploaded a complete application for the applicant’s appointment to the WCED on 5 March 2026. The applicant was subsequently appointed permanently to the post, which reflects on the school’s post establishment for 2026. The applicant has been remunerated accordingly as a Post Level 1 Educator in service of the WCED since April 2026. The applicant has received the stipend via WCED’s Persal for the period 01 January 2026 – 31 March 2026.
8. The applicant argued that she was rendering her services to the respondent as a fully qualified post level 1 Educator with effect from 01 January 2026, in a substantive and vacant post. The applicant claims that she is entitled to full remuneration and the extra 37% in lieu of benefits associated with the position, and not just the stipend paid to an underqualified Grade R practitioner for the period 01 January 2026 to 31 March 2026.
9. The applicant referred to WCED Circulars 0035/2022 and 0016/2023, paragraphs 2 and 2.1 of Circular 0016/2023, which provide for permanent employment of professionally qualified Grade R educators and require recruitment of a professionally qualified Educator when a vacancy arises within the “universalisation” cohort. These provisions support the contention that Grade R universalisation posts were intended to form part of the departmental educator establishment, subject to the applicable allocation and appointment requirements.
10. The applicant argued that Sections 3 and 4 of WCED Circular 16/2023 do not apply to the permanent appointment of fully qualified Educators when a vacancy arises. Baard testified the post was already linked to the school due to the Respondent’s universalisation process and could have been permanently filled at any moment when an incumbent could show that they were fully qualified.
11. The respondent did not have a problem backdating the appointment of Educators when the documentation takes a while to reach them. This is a regular occurrence. However, the school only uploaded the full set of documents early March 2026 and therefore the permanent appointment was made as from 01 April 2026.
    THE RESPONDENT’S CASE
12. The respondent submitted that the central issue is not whether the applicant is a fully qualified educator. Her qualifications are not in dispute.
13. The issue is whether those qualifications, together with her commencement of duties as a Grade R Educator on 1 January 2026, entitled her to be remunerated as a permanently appointed, fully qualified Post Level 1 Educator before an approved and funded post was available and the prescribed appointment process had been completed.
14. The respondent submitted that the evidence demonstrates that the applicant commenced duties as a Grade R Educator while the necessary administrative and establishment processes were still outstanding.
15. During this period, she received a stipend. Her permanent appointment was subsequently implemented with effect from 1 April 2026.
16. The respondent’s evidence, by means of oral evidence established that the Grade R position at Steenberg’s Cove Primary School was not, at the commencement of the disputed period, an approved and funded Educator post on the applicable staff establishment and this was strengthened by the fact that the school was issued a revised staff establishment letter during April 2026.
17. The evidence further established that the vacancy arose following the death of the previous incumbent in October 2025. The applicant commenced duties on 1 January 2026 while the nomination, documentation, appointment and establishment processes were being attended to.
18. The respondent’s case is that the existence of a vacancy in a Grade R class does not automatically create an approved and funded Post Level 1 educator post. The provision of educational services, the allocation of a funded post and the appointment of an Educator are related but distinct processes.
19. The respondent’s witnesses explained that remuneration at Educator salary level is dependent on the availability of an approved and funded post and compliance with the applicable appointment procedures.
20. The fact that the applicant subsequently obtained a permanent appointment with effect from 1 April 2026 is consistent with the respondent’s evidence that the necessary processes had to be completed before the salaried appointment could be implemented.
21. The respondent submits that the interpretation advanced by the applicant and supported by Baard must be tested against the full wording and purpose of Circular 0016/2023, rather than isolated provisions considered independently of the appointment and funding framework.
22. The evidence does not establish that the applicant had been permanently appointed to an approved and funded educator post with effect from 1 January 2026.
23. The documentary and oral evidence instead supports the Department’s position that the applicable processes were completed before the permanent appointment took effect on 1 April 2026.

ANALYSIS OF EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENTS
24) Having considered the evidence in this matter, I find that the applicant has not discharged the onus to show that she is entitled to the full salary applicable to a permanently qualified teacher for the period 1 January 2026 to 31 March 2026. It is necessary to state for the record that the respondent’s interpretation of Circular 0016/2023 is in my view to some extent misplaced. I agree with the union in this respect.

1. For example, the respondent referenced paragraph 3.1 that provides that permanent appointments will be made within three months of receipt of the documentation to allow administrative processes to be finalised, and that payment will be made from the date reflected on the letter of appointment. This interpretation is misplaced because that paragraph refers to a situation where an unqualified teacher obtains the status of a qualified teacher. This is not the situation of the applicant because she was already a qualified teacher when she was appointed to this position. There are other examples of the respondent’s misapplication of the circular, but it is not necessary for the purpose of this award to regurgitate this.
2. However, this misapplication is not assisting the applicant’s case. The applicant argued that it was possible for the respondent to appoint the applicant in a permanent position as from 1 January 2026. I accept this to be the case given the evidence of Baard. I have no reason the question the veracity of this evidence. This did not imply that the respondent could make the appointment from 1 January 2026 without following the approval process.
3. The totality of the evidence however indicates that the permanent appointment was only implemented on 1 April 2026. The respondent had the option of making the appointment from 1 January 2026 but before it could do so it was necessary to obtain approval.
4. The evidence demonstrate that the applicant was not appointed in a permanent capacity for the period between 1 January 2026 and 31 March 2026. The applicant is therefore not entitled to the full payment.
5. I accept the evidence and the respondent’s argument that the applicant could only have been appointed as a fully qualified post level 1 Educator once a funded post was available and the prescribed appointment process had been completed.
6. It would not make sense to expect the respondent to make the appointment permanent from 1 January 2026 before the approval process was not completed. In this regard that the staff establishment relevant to the school was updated with effect from April 2026 to reflect the permanent funded vacancy.
7. There is no evidence that the applicant was advised that she would be paid the full salary applicable to the funded vacancy when she accepted the position as from 1 January 2026.
8. The applicant was also not informed that her appointment was permanent from 1 January 2026 and that the correct salary would be backdated once the funded vacancy is approved on the staff establishment.
9. The applicant testified that she expected to be paid the full salary applicable to the substantive funded vacancy, but she did nothing to clarify upfront the terms and conditions of the employment, before accepting the position. The respondent could also have done more to avoid the confusion but in the final analysis it is my finding the applicant had not discharged the onus.
10. In the circumstances I make the following award:

AWARD
35) The applicant is not entitled to the relief sought or any relief.

CARLTON JOHNSON
SENIOR COMMISSIONER
