---
title: "20 November 2026 – ELRC305-25/26EC      "
description: "CASE NUMBER: ELRC305-25/26 EC IN THE ARBITRATION Between FUNEKA FLORENCE MBESHU APPLICANT AND DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION – EASTERN CAPE 1ST RESPONDENT MZIWAMADODA VONYA 2ND RESPONDENT ARBITRATION AWARD DATES OF HEARING 25 SEPTEMBER, 28 AND 29 OCTOBER 2026 DATE AWARD SUBMITTED…"
url: "https://elrc.org.za/docs/20-november-2026-elrc305-25-26ec/"
updated: "2026-11-20"
category: AWARDS
---

# 20 November 2026 – ELRC305-25/26EC      

CASE NUMBER: ELRC305-25/26 EC
IN THE ARBITRATION
Between

FUNEKA FLORENCE MBESHU APPLICANT
AND
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION – EASTERN CAPE 1ST RESPONDENT
MZIWAMADODA VONYA 2ND RESPONDENT

ARBITRATION AWARD

DATES OF HEARING 25 SEPTEMBER, 28 AND 29 OCTOBER 2026
DATE AWARD SUBMITTED 19 NOVEMBER 2026
NAME OF PANELIST BONGANI MTATI

```
 DETAILS OF THE HEARING AND REPRESENTATION
```

1. This matter was set down for arbitration in terms of section 191(5) of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (LRA) at the Department of Education, Ngcobo on 25 September, 28 and 29 October 2026. Mr Aaron Mhlontlo from NAPTOSA union represented the applicant, Mr Khwezi Dalasile an official from the Department of Education, represented the First Respondent and Mr Ndumiso Mbaxa from SADTU union represented the Second Respondent only on 26 September 2026, Mr Mzwamadoda Vonya.

ISSUES TO BE DECIDED
2. I am required to determine whether an unfair labour practice relating to promotion was committed. Further, depending on my finding, l am required to determine the appropriate relief.

BACKGROUND OF THE DISPUTE
3. This is a promotion dispute involving post volume 1 of 2026-56 in the Eastern Cape being the Principal post for Masonwabe Primary School at Ngcobo.
4. Applicant was teaching at Masonwabe Primary School since 2002 as post level one Educator and in 2017 applicant was appointed as Departmental Head at Masonwabe Primary school up to date. The Second Respondent being Mr Mziwamadoda Vonya was post level 4 Educator who was seconded at Masonwabe Primary School as post level one Educator.
5. After the post was advertised five candidates were shortlisted including the Second Respondent as they applied for the post and the applicant was not shortlisted for interviews, but other five shortlisted candidates were invited to the interviews where the incumbent was appointed as Principal of Masonwabe Primary School..
6. The Second Respondent’s appointment was approved by the Department of Education and assumed duties as the principal of Masonwabe Primary School.
7. The Applicant initiated her dispute by claiming that the incumbent was not qualifying for the post and she was not shortlisted despite meeting all the requirements of the post advertised in the bulletin, so lodged his dispute to ELRC for the appointment to be set aside and re-advertised.

SURVEY OF EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENTS
Employee’s case
Witness: Ms Funeka Mbeshu
8. She testified under oath that she has been an Educator of the Department of Education at Masonwabe Primary School with 23 years teaching experience as she started teaching in 2002
and she knew the incumbent as her colleague and Principal of Masonwabe Primary School as they are teaching in the same school. She submitted that her qualifications are Junior Primary teachers Diploma and Management in Education. She further stated that she was teaching all subjects including Maths at foundation phase up to date.
9. She submitted that she was challenging Principal post at Masonwabe Primary school where the incumbent was appointed by the First Respondent as the Principal in their school.
10. She referred to the bulletin where she read Masonwabe Primary School post requirements as grade 1-7 with subjects of leadership, management and mathematics as post level 3 Principal, which she applied for the post as she met the post requirements as she majored with Maths, has management course and being the Departmental Head at Masonwabe Primary School for seven years.
11. She referred to the procedure manual for the recruitment of educators, recruitment and selection policy that application form must be submitted for each vacancy and put the reference, form to be completed in full which means no gaps in the form and incomplete application form shall not be considered for sifting of candidates. He referred to the application form of the incumbent as not fully completed as the vacancy post reference was not written in full by the incumbent as he wrote the post number as 56 instead of volume 1 of 2026 -.56, referred to paragraph 16 column 5 and 6 not filled in, paragraph 20.9 and 20.10 not filled in, paragraph 21.1 to paragraph 21.4 not filled in, 24.4, 26.5, 27.2 to 27.5 not filled in, so she concluded by stating that the incumbent’s application form was not supposed to have been sifted or shortlisted as it has many unfilled gaps in contravention of the guidelines of filling in the application form..
12. She further questioned the confirmation letters from Mhlophekazi Primary School as not proper as she knew the Principal during the time of the incumbent’s time at Mhlophekazi with subjects taught by the incumbent, but not appearing in the application form. She further disputed that the incumbent taught Maths at Poswayo Primary School as she knew the teacher that taught Maths
at Poswayo Primary School being Ms Zuzo and not the incumbent as the incumbent taught Social Science, Languages and Creative Art at Masonwabe Primary School as the incumbent was brought to Masonwabe School through redeployment teaching Social Science, Xhosa and had never taught Maths at Masonwabe School even after being appointed as Principal had not taught maths. She further testified that the confirmation letter from Poswayo School was issued in 2026, but the school was already closed to issue confirmation letter for the incumbent as the Educator that signed the confirmation letter left Poswayo School in 2024 as she taught at Khanya Primary School.
13. She stated that the incumbent has Senior Primary Teaches Diploma as his qualification with no management course. She submitted that she should have been shortlisted by the panel as she had Management course obtained at WSU, has Maths in her Junior Primary Teachers Diploma and the incumbent has no Maths and Management in his qualification, although alleged to have taught Maths, which she viewed as not true.
She submitted that she prays for the setting aside of the appointment of the incumbent and or be compensated for twelve months salaries.
14. She emphasised during cross examination that an incomplete application form should not have been sifted to proceed to shortlisting as per the requirements of the respondent’s guidelines in the policies. She confirmed that her application form was also having gaps, which might be the reason for not being shortlisted, but even the incumbent should not have been shortlisted as his application form is full of gaps not filled in. She stated that the reason to leave gaps in her form was that she had filled in all the information she had, so there was no need to proceed in other spaces or would have written not available (N/A), so her application form was discarded as she was not shortlisted. She further disputed that the incumbent’s application form was complete as had gaps that were not filled in.
15. She stated during cross examination that she is at REQV 16, which she changed to say she was on REQV 14 as per the extract she showed from PAM document, so she confirmed that she has provided an incorrect information to the respondent to say was in REQV 16 instead of REQV 14.
16. She submitted during cross examination that she submitted her academic record that was to show Maths and Management as she submitted her JPTD certificate and management
certificates, but she did not submit her academic transcript for her JPTD that showed Maths from level one to level three as Cicira College was closed and records were taken to WSU where they were kept, so she agreed that she did not submit all her required documents for the panel to consider her for the post as per the requirements. She further stated that she did not submit an affidavit to confirm that she did not get her academic transcript at WSU, but she was aware to have attached, which was to confirm her maths subject as was not appearing in the JPTD certificate.
17. She confirmed during cross examination that she indicated in her application form and CV that she has Maths as she teaches it and was supposed to have done similarly with Mr Vonya who did not have Maths in his certificates, but Mr Vonya was disregarded by the panel.
18. She disputed that the incumbent was teaching Maths as she knew that he never taught Maths even post his appointment as Principal to teach Maths.
19. She disputed during cross examination that there were better candidates’ shortlisted than herself as they were not having the qualification as per the bulletin ad panel appointed a candidate with no Maths.
20. She testified during re-examination that in the shortlisting minutes there was nothing stated about the transcript as required by the panel, so there was no need to use transcript as the basis for shortlisting.
21. She emphasised that in terms of criterion of shortlisting by the panel she had management certificate as attached with the transcript to her application and the incumbent had no management certificate.
22. She retained that she was qualified better than the incumbent that has been appointed by the Respondent.
23. She emphasised that the reason for the incumbent not have taught Maths at Masonwabe even post his appointment as Principal and Maths Educator is that he does not qualify to teach Maths as per his qualifications.

RESPONDENT’S CASE
Witness: Siyabulela Zweni

1. He testified under oath that he was the circuit manager of All Saints circuit and resource person during the recruitment of the Principal post at Masonwabe Primary school. where he collected master list and application forms of the candidates from human resources to Masonwabe
   Primary School.
2. He stated that there were nine Principals, three Deputy Principals, six Heads of Department and two Educators that applied for the Principal post at Masonwabe Primary School.
3. He submitted that during short listing the panel considered requirements as based in the bulletin being Maths, leadership, management, certificate of management and management was advantageous, but emphasised that Maths was the required subject in the bulletin. He emphasised that to be shortlisted a candidate must have Maths as qualification, taught Maths at school and the panel had considered the requirements of Maths in all candidate to be shortlisted for the post. He further emphasised that a candidate should have submitted a transcript to show that she/he qualified in Maths up to level three and had taught Maths at school.
4. He submitted that in other schools Educators teach Maths with no qualification and requires to be confirmed by the Principal that he/she is teaching Maths in his school with no qualification.
5. He confirmed that the incumbent was shortlisted by the panel as he had taught Maths and had attached an affidavit that confirmed that he was not having a transcript to prove his qualification and had no Maths as qualification to teach Maths, he was the Principal of the school and experienced in management with no management certificate.
6. He submitted that the applicant was not shortlisted as the post was highly competed by four Principals, she had properly completed her form, stated that she was teaching Maths in her application form and CV, but no transcript to her application form, there was no confirmation from any school that she was teaching Maths and Maths was not appearing in her grade twelve certificate, but Maths was appearing in her application form and CV with management course in her transcript of her Advanced Certificate in Education. Senior Phase. So, the applicant was not shortlisted as she had a module in management and other candidates had certificates in management and not as a course like the applicant.
7. He submitted that the incumbent had confirmation letters from Mhlophekazi Primary School and Poswayo Primary School that he taught Maths in those schools even if he had no qualification in Maths. He stated that Poswayo was closed due to operational reasons, but the incumbent was the Principal of Poswayo Primary School and is still accountable for the activities occurring at Poswayo Primary School even if he was seconded as an Educator at Masonwabe Primary School.
8. He submitted that the post number of the Principal post of Masonwabe was Vol. 1 of 2026- 56, but the post number at Masonwabe Primary School was 56 as distinguished Masonwabe from
   other schools in the bulletin.
9. He further identified some gaps in paragraph 28 of the applicant’s application form that it was not filled in full as required and further listed all documents used during shortlisting of the candidates at Masonwabe Primary School, so he concluded that the recruitment process was free and fair as he confirmed it and declared by SADTU and NAPTOSA through signing that recruitment process form that the process was free and fair to indicate that the panel was successful in its work of appointing a principal of Masonwabr Primary School.
10. He confirmed during cross examination that the school governing body (SGB) was trained and he was part of the training of the SGBs where they were using the Personal Administrative Measures document, post bulletin vol.1 of 2026 and other documents used to train SGBs. He further confirmed that they did not get minutes of the meeting declaring the post at school as he was not the circuit manager then, so he did not get such information.
11. He confirmed during cross examination that Masonwabe Primary School advertised Maths as a subject that was a school need that needs an educator that qualified in Maths as a major to teach at school and the incumbent has no qualification in Maths, so the incumbent did not qualify for the post at Masonwabe primary School.
12. He further confirmed that the incumbent had not complied with 2.4 of the post bulletin advert that incumbent had to complete post number of the vacancy for which the application is made, as the incumbent filled in only 56 as part of the post number which was not complete as the post number was Vol.1 of 2026-56.
13. He further stated during cross examination that during shortlisting they considered nine criterions, but other criterions to make thirteen were added by the secretary as they were discussed by the panel, which he confirm them, but were originally nine and not thirteen.
14. He further confirmed all the documents submitted by the SGB to his office for the recruitment process of the principal post at Masonwabe primary School was completed as signed by the chairperson of the SGB of the school and circuit manager, being himself.
15. He confirmed during cross examination that he did not ask for the original confirmation letter from Mhlophekazi Primary school as the incumbent brought a copy of the confirmation letter.
16. He further confirmed during cross examination that the incumbent did not bring reference check record during the interviews as he was not aware.
17. He disputed during cross examination that the confirmation letter from Poswayo School was a copy as he had seen it as original document.
18. He further confirmed during cross examination that Poswayo Primary School was closed and
    educators were transferred to other schools and not sure what happened to the assets including the stamp of the school and he could not confirm principal of Poswayo School whether was issued with letter as accounting officer in 2026 or not. He further confirmed that when Ms Zuza was signing a letter of confirmation of the incumbent, the school was already closed and was not correct to portray Ms Zuza as principal of Poswayo School.
19. He stated that the did not shortlist the applicant as she had no certificate in management, but had course in management and application form and curriculum vitae were not enough to prove that the applicant had Maths as she was competing with candidates with certificates in management and being principals of the schools and applicant had no transcript during shortlisting to show her Maths at tertiary level.
20. He stated during cross examination that he was not aware that an educator that was participating in Maths programs at Poswayo Primary School was Ms Zozi and not the incumbent as he was not teaching Maths. He further admitted that the incumbent was not teaching Maths at Masonwabe Primary School since his arrival up to beyond his appointment as Principal and maths educator at Masonwabe Primary School.
21. He submitted during re-examination that the SGB recommends the appointment of the Principal at schools as was done to the incumbent and the appointing authority is the Head of the Department who delegated such power to the District Directors.

2ND RESPONDENT’S CASE

Witness: Mziwamadoda Vonya

1. He testified under oath that he was the second respondent in this case as he was appointed as the Principal of Masonwabe Primary School which was being challenged by the applicant.
2. He submitted that he was teaching at Masonwabe Primary School prior to the recruitment of the post of Principal’s advertisement, as he was post level one educator.
3. He submitted that the former Principal convened a meeting of the staff to profile the post and have noticed the post in the bulletin as advertised as was per their profiling meeting.
4. He stated that after the bulletin has been issued with the post of Masonwabe Primary School, he applied for the post of Principal, shortlisted, interviewed and appointed as the successful candidate for the post of Principal at Masonwabe Primary School. He stated that he was introduced as the Principal of Masonwabe Primary School by the Circuit Manager and resumed
   his duties as the Principal of the school.
5. He submitted that he qualified for the post of Principal as he had the requirements of the post being leadership and management as he was the Principal of the school at Poswayo Primary School, but due to operational requirement at Poswayo Primary School, he was seconded at Masonwabe Primary School as an educator.
6. He submitted that he never taught Maths at Masonwabe Primary School as there were six educators with Maths, but he had taught Maths at Mhlophekazi Primary School and Poswayo Primary School, so he had experience in teaching Maths. He further stated that he had Senior Primary Teachers Diploma with Geography, History and languages, so he admitted that he did not have Maths in his qualifications.
7. He further disputed that he never taught Maths at Mhlophekazi and Poswayo Primary Schools as he taught them as indicated from the records of those schools as per the confirmation letters from those schools.
8. He confirmed during cross examination that the educators that have issued the confirmation letter to him were not there at Mhlophekazi during his time, but they have used records at school to issue such confirmation letter.
9. He confirmed during cross examination that he never taught Maths at Masonwabe primary School as he was teaching Social Science and languages, but he considered himself suitable for the post as he had experience in teaching Maths and management,
10. He further admitted during cross examination that he had no teaching methodology in Maths as he had not done it at tertiary level.
11. He further confirmed during cross examination that he did not have original copy of the confirmation letter from Mhlophekazi. Primary School.
12. He was unable to respond during cross examination why he submitted scanned documents instead of the original documents, which he confirmed as his documents.
13. He further stated during cross examination that he was not appointed by the district director as the accounting officer of Poswayo Primary School in 2026, but he disputed that he had no authority to issue letters at Poswayo Primary School as he had items in his possession from Poswayo Primary School. He further confirmed that he was together with Ms Marhamba when his confirmation letter was written and signed with different signatures in the letter as they differ by letter Z, but he was using his only one signature and disputed that his signature was fraudulently obtained.
14. He confirmed during cross examination that he never participated in any Maths programmes
    and what’s up group when he was at Poswayo Primary School as he was busy and unable to attend Maths programmes as he last attended Maths programmes at Mhlophekazi Primary Scho
    ANALYSIS OF EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENTS
15. It is trite that the employee bears an onus to prove an unfair labour practice as defined in section 186(2) of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995(LRA) was committed by the Respondent. The Applicant has to convince the arbitrator that the conduct of the Respondent amounted to an unfair labour practice as defined and distilled from applicable jurisprudence and as envisaged in the law.
16. I have considered the departmental guidelines for interview procedures, post requirements as per the advert, as well as relevant case law. I have further considered the Collective Agreement 1 of 2024 clause 6.7 on shortlisting candidates that were acting in the post advertised, which there was no evidence led to that effect and the post requirements in the advert of the bulletin as the school advertised were Maths, leadership and management as per the school needs as testified by the resource person Mr Zweni and corroborated by the applicant and the incumbent.
17. Section 186(2) of the LRA reads as follows: “unfair labour practice any unfair act or that omission arises between an employer and the employee involving, unfair conduct by the employer relating to the promotion, demotion, probation (excluding disputes about unfair dismissals for a reason relating to probation) or training of an employee relating to the provision of benefits to an employee”. In this case unfair labour practice involves promotion.
18. I have to decide whether the First Respondent acted fairly or not in not appointing the Applicant in the position of the Principal and whether the incumbent was procedurally and substantively appointed fairly by the second respondent as Principal at Masonwabe Primary school.
19. I start by considering procedural fairness in the promotional employment process of the incumbent in the Principal post at Masonwabe Primary school.
20. As this is Principal promotional post, in terms of the Employment of Educators Act PAM
    Regulations the role of the departmental officials as resource persons is to assist the School
    Governing Body (SGB) towards the appointment of qualifying school management by giving control to manage appointment processes. The resource person will be responsible to ensure that capacity building sessions is conducted with the interview committee to enhance its understanding of the selection and interview processes, so in this case the resource person
    being Mr Zweni was appointed and no challenge against the resource person by the applicant.
    I also find that the incumbent has failed to comply with the requirements of filling in the application form as he failed to write the complete post reference number being Vol.1 of 2026-56 as he wrote 56 as the post reference number, had some gaps not filled in paragraphs 16 columns 5 and 6, paragraphs 20.9 and 20.10, paragraph 21.1 to paragraphs 20.4 as testified by the applicant and corroborated by Mr Zweni during cross examination and visible in the incumbent’s application form, which l view that the incumbent should not have been sifted or shortlisted as per the requirements of filling in of the application form in terms of clause 2.4 and 3.4 on application and procedure when applying of Annexure A on Guidelines and Procedures on filling of vacant school based educator posts.
21. Considering post requirements, l find that the Second Respondent was not qualified for the post of Principal as the post was advertised in the bulletin required Maths, management and leadership, which the incumbent had no Maths and Management as required as per the advert of the post, which he confirmed to have experience in management as was the Principal of Poswayo Primary School and had no Maths as he taught Maths at Mhlophekazi and Poswayo Primary Schools, but had not done Maths at tertiary level as was further corroborated by the applicant and Mr Zweni. So, l view that the incumbent did not qualify to the post as advertised and was emphasised by the resource person during cross examination that the incumbent did not qualify to be appointed in the post of Principal at Masonwabe Primary School as he had no Maths and Management as was corroborated by the applicant. I further consider the reason of the applicant not being shortlisted by the panel was that there were many candidates with management certificate than the applicant who had a course in management and not a full management course certificate, but l find that the SGB recommended and appointed the incumbent who had no management and Maths, which I view unfair to the applicant and those candidates with management certificates to appoint the incumbent with no management certificate at all, which was a requirement in the advert.
22. Considering the applicant, l find that the applicant had Maths in her Junior Primary Teachers Diploma, which she taught at school as per her application form and curriculum vitae, but with no further document confirming that she had Maths as there was no transcript during the recruitment that confirmed that she had Maths as a major subject at tertiary level, although she submitted her JPTD transcript post recruitment process of the post in question. She also had Management course as per her academic transcript for her Advanced Certificate in Education:
    Senior Phase, which l view made the applicant better than the incumbent that was appointed in the post as per the required subjects in the advert, as the incumbent had no Maths and Management. I reject the submission that the applicant had no further reference to confirm the subjects she taught as she had provided some references as educators in her curriculum vitae (CV) to confirm her subjects she taught in those schools listed in her CV.
23. Therefore, I conclude that the incumbent’s appointment must be set aside as he has no required qualifications as per the advert in the bulletin volume 1 of 2026-56 dated 5 February 2026, which l view as basic requirement for the qualified candidate to be appointed to be having Maths, Management and leadership, so l view experience and interview performance are added advantages for appointment consideration and not basic post requirements.
24. Considering relief sought by the Applicant that the Second Respondent’s appointment be set aside or applicant to be compensated with twelve month salaries, l conclude that the appointment of the incumbent must be set aside as he was not qualifying to be appointed as Principal based on not meeting the required post qualifications as per the advert in the bulletin being Maths, Management and Leadership, so the post of principal for Masonwabe Primary School must be set aside to be re-advertised.
25. .” To determine if the failure to promote the employee was unfair the court in Ndlovu v CCMA and others (2000) 21 ILJ 1653(LC) stated that: “it can never suffice in relation to any such question for the complainant to say that he/she is qualified by experience, ability and technical
    qualifications such as university degree and the like for the post that is merely the hurdle. The next hurdle is of equal if not greater importance. It is to show that the decision to appoint someone else to the post in preference to the complainant was unfair”.
    In this case l view that the appointment of the Second Respondent by the first respondent was procedurally and substantively unfair as his application did not comply with the minimum requirements of the required subjects as per the advert in the bulletin as the incumbent had no Maths and Management, but was appointed in contravention of such basic requirements of advertised subjects in the bulletin. So I conclude that the Applicant proved the necessity for the remedy he sought, that the appointment of the incumbent be set aside at Masonwabe Primary School. Considering compensation as an alternative remedy for the applicant, l find that it will be unfair to grant such remedy as there were other candidates whom l believe have been unfairly affected by the decision to appoint the incumbent, so weighing up these reasons, l conclude that l must set aside the appointment of the incumbent in the post of Masonwabe Primary School to be re-advertised in the next bulletin in 2027.
26. Based on the evidence before me, I find that the Applicant proved on a balance of probabilities that the incumbent was not qualifying to be appointed as Principal at Masonwabe Primary
    School as he had no required qualifications of Maths, Management and Leadership, which I conclude that it was unfair to the applicant who had some subjects as required in the advert than the incumbent with no subjects as required by the school as per the advertisement.
27. I, therefore set aside the appointment of the Second Respondent Mziwamadoda Vonya and order that this post be re-advertised as it was advertised prior this recruitment process and issued in the next bulletin.

AWARD
49. I find that the First Respondent committed an unfair labour practice relating to promotion as is intended in section 186 (2) (a) of the LRA against the Applicant for appointing the unqualified Second Respondent as Principal of Masonwabe Primary School.
50. The appointment of the Second Respondent being Mziwamadoda Vonya is set aside with effect from 31 December 2026.
51. The First Respondent is ordered to re-advertise this post similarly with as was advertised prior this recruitment process in the next bulletin to be issued in 2027.
52. No order is made to costs.
Signature:

Commissioner: Bongani Mtati
Sector: Basic Education
