View Categories

17 November 2026 – ELRC736-25/26EC

Case Number: ELRC 736-25/26EC
Commissioner: BONGANI MTATI
Date of Award: 16 NOVEMBER 2026

In the ARBITRATION between

NEHAWU obo ZOTHANI NTOMBEBELE
( Applicant)

and

DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION AND TRAINING- KING HINTSA TVET COLLEGE
(Respondent)

DETAILS OF THE HEARING AND REPRESENTATION
[1] This is the award in the arbitration between Ntombebele Zothani the Applicant, and Department of Higher Education and Training- KING HINTSA TVET College, the Respondent. The arbitration was held under the auspices of the ELRC in terms of section 191(5)(a) of the Labour Relations Act, 1995 as amended (“the Act”) and this award is issued in terms of section 138 (7) of the Act.
[2] The arbitration hearing took place at King Hintsa Tvet College on the 11 December 2025, 25 and 26 May, 27 July, 12, 13 and14 October 2026, the Applicant was present and represented by Mr Vuyani Zweni, a NEHAWU union official.
[3] The Respondent was represented by Mr Zizwe Maliwa a labour relations official of the respondent.
[4] The proceedings were manually and digitally recorded.

ISSUE TO BE DECIDED

[5] I am to determine whether the Applicant’s dismissal was procedurally and substantively fair. If l find that the Applicant’s dismissal was unfair, l am further required to determine the appropriate relief.
BACKGROUND TO THE DISPUTE
[6] It was common cause that the Applicant worked for the Respondent as a lecturer of the respondent since 25 March 2010 up to her dismissal.
[7] The Applicant was dismissed on 10 June 2024 and was earning R31397-38 a month at the time of her dismissal.
[8] The Respondent is the Department of Higher Education and Training King Hintsa Tvet College, an educational institution dealing with teaching, learning and providing skills to the students where the applicant was lecturing students.
[9] The Applicant challenged procedural and substantive fairness of her dismissal.
[10] The Applicant is seeking retrospective reinstatement as a relief.

SURVEY OF THE EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENT
[11] Both parties had their bundles of documents named as A for the applicant and B for the respondent.
RESPONDENT’S CASE
Witness 1 Adv. Joseph Tokelo Chiloane
[12] He testified under oath that he was the Director of a Law firm and was the principal of Tshwane South TVET College when appointed as the chairperson of the hearing.
[13] He stated that he had to take a decision based on the evidence presented in the case, where he will stand firm for the decision he took.
[14] He submitted that he allowed all parties to present any in limine issues, but no party raised an in limine issue.
[15] He stated that he viewed the sanction appropriate as the applicant was charged with five counts of charges being failure to collect appointment letters to conduct invigilation and had found the applicant breached the rule based on evidence and policies of the respondent. He stated that the applicant was aware of the invigilation as she was informed in the meeting that invigilation is compulsory for lecturers as part of their
inherent duties.
[16] On charge 2 that the applicant failed to invigilate examinations for November 2022 by not participating in the invigilation and compelled the respondent to hire invigilators and incurred cost of about R450000-00 due to applicant not invigilating examinations.
[17] On charge 3 that the applicant performed poorly other than incapacity as applicant failed to teach and complete syllabus as negatively affected student’s performance due to applicant’s withdrawal of her labour. He disputed that the applicant had not enough time to teach as schools opened late, as applicant was offered catch up time in April 2023, but refused to participate in it.
[18] On charge 4 the applicant was charged by holding an unauthorised meeting with staff where the applicant was authorised to convene a meeting, but she did not comply with the notice of convening the meeting as she failed to hold the meeting within 48 hours and inform the management. He further submitted that the applicant chaired the meeting without authorisation and failed to check access for the safety of the venue for the meeting she held, so she breached the rule.
[19] He stated during cross examination that she did not know the applicant’s trade union, although applicant stated that she was a shop steward, but she failed to canvass such during the hearing and he would dispute that the applicant was a shop steward even if they would have brought a letter, as the employer was not aware that the applicant was a shop steward.
[20] He did not dispute the letter dated 23 January 2023 that was introducing executive members, which the applicant was part of it, but emphasised that he was not aware that the applicant was a shop steward.
[21] He confirmed that the applicant was not the only one who failed to invigilate as they were eight and all have been charged. He further confirmed other lecturers who did not invigilate, but not charged, which he heard such in passing as he was never presented to him as an in limine issue.
[22] He denied that he had received a letter of grievances from the union site committee raising about issues on IQMS, catch up and management challenges as he saw it for the first time in the arbitration, but heard about them in passing including examination irregularities.
[23] He submitted during cross examination that the applicant was not only dismissed for examination irregularities as was found to have breached other rules like not completing syllabus, conducting illegal meeting in the campus and inciting staff.
[24] He submitted that the applicant during the hearing stated that the trust relationship between her and the management has broken down irretrievable, so he disputed that the applicant was referring to the management as management is employed by the department.
[25] He explained during cross examination that the duty of an employer during unprotected strike is to charge the employees involved in strike and an ultimatum was issued to the employees participated in the strike to go back to work, but employees refused.
[26] He confirmed that the catch up plan was initiated by the applicant and was agreed later to be implemented by the management, but applicant refused to participate in catch up plan as per the evidence led during hearing.

Witness 2: Anele Potelwa
[27] He testified under oath that he was the campus manager for the Dutywa campus in 2021 and was permanently employed in 2022 as campus manager and he knew the applicant as the former lecturer at Dutywa, who was also a unionist of NEHAWU. He explained that he had never any query with the applicant until the applicant was elected to be a union activist where they mainly have differences between the union and the management.
[28] He submitted that when he was appointed as campus manager at Dutywa, he was not welcomed by NEHAWU members as they requested management to remove him from the post of campus manager. He referred to the memorandum he received from the applicant’s union where he was alleged to have been issuing marks for IQMS and there was no proper way of regulating IQMS for lecturers to obtain scores.
[29] He submitted that in November 2022 lecturers refused to invigilate if they were not to be compensated for invigilation under his chaotic management, which he disputed the allegation as not true as students were admitted based on their applications, admitted to the campus to study and set for assessment to evaluate students for progression.
[30] He testified that the applicant refused to collect time tables for the invigilation of students writing their November 2022 examination, which she breached the rule on examination and refused a valid instruction to collect invigilation letters. He stated that he informed lecturers to collect their letters in meetings, through emails, sent messages as lecturer’s primary duty to invigilate students when writing examinations, but lecturers refused.
[31] He referred to charge 2 where he stated that the applicant failed invigilate students when writing their 2022 November, March and June 2023 examinations and when he called the applicant she informed him that they agreed as union not to invigilate examinations.
[32] He submitted that the applicant failed to teach students as she failed to complete required work at that specific time and students were prejudiced, failed to participate in registration, did not report in classes, could not provide tasks to students as she produced one task out of required three tasks.
[33] He explained the unauthorised meeting convened by the applicant that it was not authorised by the management as they were invited to a meeting that was already organised, which he attended it with his management team and they found in the meeting that it was about misconduct of the campus management team. He stated that the applicant proceeded with the item they requested to be removed before attending the meeting as was humiliating the management of the campus to be incompetent, which the applicant failed to remove it in the meeting.
[34] He confirmed during cross examination that he changed character of the process of IQMS on his arrival and disputed that the applicant was refused to attend external marking as she failed to collect invigilation letters, but was refused due to not meeting other requirement to attend external marking of papers. He confirmed that the applicant was with other lecturers that were refused to attend marking as they all failed to meet the required standards to attend marking. He further disputed that the applicant was not permitted to invigilate supplementary examinations.
[35] He submitted during cross examination that the total number of lecturers that refused to invigilate examinations were 15, but only 7 or 8 charged and sanctioned by the respondent, so he knew nothing why those lecturers not charged and sanctioned as
their case was handled by the disciplinary committee.
[36] He denied that that he had a relationship with a student that was caught with a book during examination and he viewed as a peripheral issue to the issue in question.
[37] He confirmed during cross examination that the two lady lecturers involved in the allegations of invigilation irregularities were already serving in the committee and there was no conflict of interest to them in the committee.
[38] He emphasised that the catch up plan initiated by the applicant was refused and later the management brought up a recovery plan, which was refused by the applicant and other lecturers which led to suffering to the students as some had uncompleted assessment tasks and hired some lecturer to close the gap, but some few lecturers participated in the recovery plan organised by the management. He indicated that there was no change in the examination time table.
[39] He emphasised during re-examination that the applicant refused to render her services to the college in 2022.

Witness 3: Yandiswa Mayekiso
[40] She testified under oath that she was the senior lecturer of the Dutywa campus since 2010 and she knew the applicant as former lecturer at Dutywa who was charged with failure to carry out a lawful instruction to collect invigilation letters to invigilate November 2022 examinations and finally did not invigilate November 2022 examinations, so her matter with other lecturers was escalated to the senior management, where they were charged and dismissed. She further submitted that the applicant failed to invigilate and was her charge 2 as she did not invigilate November 2022 examinations in the campus. She further emphasised that it is part of the lecturer’s duty to invigilate examination, her refusal led to be charged and sanctioned for failure to invigilate examinations.
[41] She stated that the applicant was further charged for failure to complete the syllabus as she failed to complete all required tasks of assessment to the detriment of the students, so the applicant failed to comply with the required work of the semester in 2023.
[42] She further submitted that the applicant was charged for convening a staff meeting
without authorisation as she was the chairperson of the meeting.
[43] She further explained that during the meeting she was humiliated and ridiculed by the applicant being her senior in the presence of other junior’s lecturers that she must be professional in her conduct and was reported to senior management as she was not to take action on her own, but senior management had to act on her behalf.
[44] She submitted that her relations with the applicant were good before Mr Potelwa’s appointment as campus manager, but drastically changed after the appointment of Mr Potelwa as a manager.
[45] She submitted during cross examination that charge 1 occurred in November 2022 and continued in 2023 as applicant failed to collect invigilation letters, not invigilated examinations of the students and failure to teach students and charge 5 on convening meeting without authorisation and charge 6 on humiliation of herself occurred in 2022 and reported it to the principal of the campus.
[46] She confirmed during cross examination that invigilation is part of lecture’s duties, but external invigilation is paid to lecturers.
[47] She confirmed during cross examination that the initial catch up plan was drafted by the applicant to start in February 2023, but it was not a right time to deal with it and applicant and other lecturers refused to participate in April 2023 catch up plan organised by the management as Mr Potelwa requested extension of time from Department of Higher Education and Training, which was granted and did not know whether applicant was aware or not.
[48] She disputed that she knew about examination irregularities and the student implicated on irregularities was absent from the school as per the records and some lecturers involved in such irregularities were issued with warnings.

Witness 4: Nobom Magwaca
[49] She testified that she was the senior lecturer of Dutywa campus and she knew the applicant as the former lecturer who reported to her at Dutywa campus.
[50] She submitted that the applicant was charged for insubordination as she failed to collect invigilation letters from the chief invigilator and further failed to invigilate November 2022 examination as she demanded compensation to invigilate and as was
not granted such compensation, she did not invigilate November 2022 examinations.
[51] She stated that she reported the applicant for refusing to collect invigilation letters and further failed to invigilate November 2022 and the campus management opted to hire invigilators to continue with examinations.
[52] She further explained that the applicant failed to complete her term work as she did not complete syllabus with outstanding assessment tasks of the student that put the students at a detriment not to perform well in their examinations.
[53] She stated that the applicant was further charged for convening unauthorised meeting, which she chaired in the presence of the management as she refused to hand over the meeting to the management as per their agreement that the meeting shall be chaired by the manager, Mr Potelwa and remove item of management challenges.
[54] She stated that in the staff meeting the applicant humiliated them in the presence of junior staff as she stated that the management was treating lecturers like their kids especially Ms Mayekiso as her name was mentioned many times as the disrespectful senior in the campus and they were pointed by fingers by the applicant showing disrespect to them
[55] She stated during cross examination that her relationship with the applicant was good.
[56] She submitted that the total number of lectures participated in not invigilating in November 2022 were 15, but only 8 were charged and other 7 lecturers were not charged for the reason she did not know, but they proceeded with their work in 2023 as charged lecturers continued refusing to work, but ultimately the applicant joined lecturers that worked as she marked supplementary papers. She stated that the applicant stopped working after supplementary examinations.
[57] She disputed that the applicant was not dismissed for 2022 November examinations, as the applicant was charged in 2023 for 2022 examinations failure to invigilate.
[58] She stated that there were also complaints from students that were tabled in the meeting and in writing about the management. She further confirmed the letter received by the management from NEHAWU alleging about the misconduct of the management, IQMS, external marking, invigilation and others. She submitted that it was stated in the meeting that lecturers will not be released for external work like marking and invigilation if not completed her work and
disputed that Teko campus lecturers were released for marking having not completed the required work to be released for marking.
[59] She confirmed that the initial catch up plan initiated by the applicant was refused by the management as teaching had not started, but when teaching started the management introduced catch up plan in April 2023 where some fifteen lectures refused to participate including the applicant.
[60] She referred to the government gazette where remuneration for examination related issued is paid, which she stated that only external invigilation shall be paid and not remunerating internal invigilation according to the gazette.

[61] Witness 5: Tembelihle Ntlangano
[62] He testified that he was the principal of Ikhala TVET College and during the incident of this case was the acting principal from 2022 to 2024.
[63] He submitted that he was reported by the campus manager, Mr Potelwa that lecturers in his campus were refusing to invigilate November 2022 examination, which he visited the campus, held meetings where he advised lecturers to invigilate examinations as was their inherent duty to perform, but lecturers refused to him as they demanded remuneration to invigilate external papers.
[64] He stated that he instructed Mr Potelwa to issue all lecturers with notice to collect their examination letters to invigilate the examinations, which they failed to collect those letters and they did not invigilate examinations. He stated that as a result of lecturers refusing to invigilate, they incurred costs to hire external invigilators to invigilate students.
[65] He submitted that the applicant and other lecturers continued refusing to work at the college as they did not assist in registration of students and did not teach at the beginning of the year, but attended to their complaint which they finalised in March 2023 and started their teaching and marked March supplementary examinations.
[66] He explained that they were left behind in the syllabus where they organised a catch up recovery plan where some lecturers refused to participate and they organised external lecturers to proceed with catch up plan.
[67] He submitted that after all these incidents, they charged the lecturers for misconduct.
[68] He submitted that during their meetings with staff at Dutywa campus, some lectures realised their plight and moved away themselves from the further misconduct of other lecturers.
[69] He confirmed that he received a correspondence inviting members to a meeting from NEHAWU as written by the applicant as secretary or chairperson of the union and had meetings with applicant representing members.
[70] He testified during cross examination that he was aware of the state of the campus document as was issued by NEHAWU on issues of IQMS where lecturers’IQMS was delayed to be submitted, but was finally attended to and corrected. On the issue of external marking, lecturers were never released due to not meeting the requirements of external marking as lecturers did not invigilate, did not complete their work, so lectures failed to meet the requirements to attend external marking. He disputed that there were lectures at Teko campus that attended external marking having not met the required marking standards as their matter was investigated and not yet finalised, he left the campus and challenges were attended by other managers.
[71] He confirmed that the applicant came with catch up plan in February 2023 when still busy with registration and not yet started teaching, which he refused to authorised it and management organised another catch up in April 2023 where the applicant and other lecturers refused to participate to it.
[72] He referred to the annexure S of remuneration of invigilation that his understanding of the document is that invigilators are paid for their external invigilation only as they are not paid for internal invigilation’s, so it was common continuous norm for internal invigilation not remunerated for lecturers, so internal invigilation is not paid

APPLICANT’S CASE

[73] Witness: Ms Ntombebele Zothani
[74] She testified under oath that she was the lecturer of the respondent who was charged and dismissed for alleged misconducts
[75] She submitted that charge 1 was alleged for failure to carry out a reasonable instruction on appointment letters for November 2022 examinations, which she stated
that she did not refuse to collect invigilation letters and to invigilate as they had meeting with management to remunerate lecturers invigilating internal papers and they could not reach agreement, engaged senior management and failed as Mr Ntlangano further raised an issue of budget, which the management escalated to the Department of Higher Education and Training and was not resolved. She further submitted that they advised the management to do viarment on the budget to accommodate them to be paid for invigilation, but the management refused, so they had agreed as lecturers not to invigilate if they were not to be remunerated for invigilation.
[76] She emphasised that they asked the management to bring policy on their issue of invigilation remuneration, but the acting principal became arrogant and failed to bring source document on remuneration of invigilators and ultimately closed the meeting chaotically. She stated that ultimately, she did not invigilate November 2022 examinations as she did not collect an appointment letter to invigilate.
[77] She stated that external lecturers are remunerated for marking and invigilation’s as per their understanding that external invigilators are hired from outside and remunerated for their invigilation work.
[78] She referred to annexure S for remuneration for examination related work where she interpreted the annexure to mean that lecturers must be paid for internal invigilation as it is done in external examinations.
[79] On charge 2 that she failed to invigilate November 2022 examination, which she disputed the charge as there was no document produced to them by the management to invigilate examination without remuneration. She referred to human resource job description where she stated that there was no mention of invigilation as their inherent job.
[80] On charge for allegations of failure to teach and cover syllabus of students, she disputed the charge as she tabled various reasons that led to non- completion of the syllabus as that classes started late as there were delays caused by online applications, class list was finalised late around March 2023, classes started on the 20 February 2023, strikes, and requested catch up plan from the management which was refused by the management.
[81] She stated that they even informed Mr Ngubelanga from the DHET about extending
time for tuition, but unsucceful. She stated that she taught students during the time of
their syllabuses.
[82] She clarified that the management issued their catch up recovery plan in April 2023, which they refused it as they viewed as crafted to frustrate them as it was a short period of time. She further stated that the catch up plan in April was during examinations time, which they viewed clashing with examinations, so was not permissible to run teaching and examinations simultaneously.
[83] On charge 5 on convening the staff meeting without authorisation, she stated that she disputed the charge as they requested the meeting from the management which was granted by campus manager, Mr Potelwa with some amendments in the agenda, which was refused by the meeting, so she proceeded with the meeting as management also attended the meeting as per their request to convene meeting and invitation of the management to attend the meeting,
[84] On charge 6 insulting management, she disputed the charge as she knew her relationship with Ms Mayekiso was good as was testified by Ms Mayekiso. She stated that there were issues raised by the staff to the management in general where she advised the meeting to be respectful to others to discuss and resolve their issues amicable with the management.
[85] She stated that she was the shop steward when charged as she was an additional member in the campus executive and shop steward in her campus, so her union was not informed of her charges, but the management was aware that she was the shop steward in the campus.
[86] She referred to the extension of time for catch up plan, which she stated that they were not aware of it as has been informed to others and not to other fifteen lecturers.
[87] She testified that there were lecturers who were involved in examination irregularities who attend external marking, but were not supposed to have attended marking as per the examination requirements.
[88] She confirmed that they were fifteen lecturers that did not invigilate in November 2022 and did not finish their term class work, but only eight lecturers charged and dismissed, so she viewed the respondent inconsistent in the campus as they should have been all charged and dismissed for similar misconduct. She testified during cross examination that she had good relationship with the management and Mr Potelwa was employed before to the institution than herself.
[89] She stated during cross examination that she disputed charge 1 as she felt sanction was harsh for failure to invigilate and collect letter for invigilation as the matter was still under discussion, which she confirmed that she did not invigilate and collect invigilation letters from the respondent.
[90] She stated that the issue of invigilation was there years before, but attended by other managers with flexi time where invigilators were allowed to come to school during invigilation and leave after examinations, so they viewed as fine for them than to total refusal to consider invigilation remuneration.
[91] She disputed that they were not accepting Mr Potelwa with their conduct in 2022, but was for him to address their demands as lecturers as he was getting into their nerves with his improper administration. She emphasised that they gave Mr Potelwa a chance to administer the campus, but was unable to resolve issues as he did not know the policies to be used to administer the campus.
[92] She confirmed during cross examination that Mr Potelwa was worse in administering the campus as things became worse during his time and refer to the examples of absence of text books, poor registration administration, there were no contact meetings as was promoting use of emails, there were camps amongst the staff and some lecturers were not included in campus programs.
[93] She confirmed during cross examination that she had good relations with Mr Potelwa, but things changed after invigilation issue, so she would dispute that they did not give him a chance to administer the campus.
[94] She confirmed during cross examination that she was a shop steward of the campus but made it easy to be understood as chairperson of the union in the campus since 2023 as per the election of the union and letter submitted to the campus.
[95] She disputed that it was for the first time for the union to invite management into their meeting as management used to be invited to a union meeting with executive only and not with entire membership of the union.
[96] She disputed that Mr Potelwa granted permission to convene their meeting on condition that he was to chair the meeting, as it was their meeting with their agenda,
so she chaired the meeting as was granted by Mr Potelwa, the campus manager.
[97] She disputed that Ms Mayekiso was insulted as incompetent by the staff, as Ms Mayekiso was informed of incompetency in attending staff issues like their medical certificates, which was resolved and not as an insult to Ms Mayekiso, so the management was lying on insulting them.
[98] She confirmed during the staff meeting that Ms Mayekiso apologised for her unwanted statements in the meeting, as she was the one who blasted in the meeting against the staff, so she apologised for her conduct.
[99] She confirmed that she did not complete syllabus due to time constraints and catch up plan refused by management as they brought their catch up plan late, which she did not participate as was during examination time, as she viewed that it brought confusion to them as lecturers, so she did not participate in the catch up.
[100] She disputed that lecturers may not be paid invigilation remuneration as they are full time lecturers similarly as external invigilators who are paid their invigilation remuneration.
[101] She stated that the issue of preliminary on the issue of shop steward was raised by the union in her hearing, but was refused with no reasons by the chairperson.

Witness 2: Nonkululeko Mpehla
[102] She testified that she was the lecturer at of the respondent at Dutywa campus and she knew the applicant as her former colleague who was dismissed for reasons unknown to her as she heard that she was dismissed for misconduct related to invigilation.
[103] She submitted that she did not participate in invigilation in 2022 and she was not disciplined for not invigilating as others were disciplined and dismissed by the respondent. She further listed other seven lecturers that were not disciplined by the respondent as they all committed the same offence of not invigilating November 2022 examinations and did not complete syllabus in 2023, but she did not know why they were not disciplined whereas others were disciplined including the applicant.
[104] She submitted that they took a decision as lecturers not to invigilate and not the union took such decision as they found that lecturers were supposed to have been paid for invigilation, which was not happening in their campus, so they were demanding
payment for examination invigilation.
[105] She disputed that they were not to be paid as they were promised to be paid by the management.
[106] She confirmed during cross examination that the applicant did not invigilate in March 2023, but marked supplementary examination papers.
Witness 3: Zimkita Mabentsela
[107] She testified that she was the lecturer of the respondent at Dutywa campus since March 2014.
[108] She referred to management report on lecturers that refused to invigilate November 2022 examinations where she stated that fifteen lecturers took a resolution not to invigilate examinations, but eight of them were charged and dismissed and others including herself were not charged and dismissed as they did not participate in the invigilation and finishing the syllabus. She stated that the other seven lecturers are still employed in the college, although they participated in not invigilating November 2022 examinations.
[109] She confirmed during cross examination that they were union members that refused to invigilate and all fifteen lecturers were members of NEHAWU.
[110] She stated during cross examination that they were invigilating in the previous years without remunerations, but they have realised that they were entitled to the payment of invigilation as external invigilators were paid, so they embarked on the demand of being remunerated for invigilating in the campus.
[111] She referred to the previous manager’s style that they were not paid directly, but were issued with some kind of incentives to invigilate examinations.
[112] She disputed that they wanted the college to collapse as they did not want Mr Potelwa as campus manager.
[113] She confirmed during cross examination that they were issued with lawful instruction to collect invigilation letters to invigilate November 2022 examinations, but they refused as were not to be remunerated by the management for invigilation.

[114] Witness 4: Sanelisiwe Samora Mrwetyana

[115] He testified that he was the lecturer of the respondent at Msobomvu campus since 2013 and is a member of the executive committee of NEHAWU as was elected in the congress in January 2023.
[116] He referred to the email that was sent by the union to the respondent informing about their executive to the respondent as was elected as secretary and applicant was elected as additional member.
[117] He submitted that he was the representative of the applicant in the hearing where he informed the chairperson of the hearing that they were never informed that their member who was a shop steward was charged as per the requirement of the Labour Relations Act, but the chairperson did not consider their submission, and disputed that saying there was no proof that the applicant was a shop steward as there was no letter confirming the applicant that she was the shop steward.
[118] He submitted that the applicant was dismissed for failing to teach students as required by the respondent in 2023, but there was no mention of 2023 in the charge, as only 2022 appears in the charge.
[119] He submitted during cross examination that applicant was elected to become a shop steward and their collective duty as the executive was to represent employees at workplace where they meet management on scheduled and emergency meetings for employee’s rights and welfare.
[120] He stated during cross examination that they were part of the resolution team that attended to the issues of invigilation at Dutywa campus, but the management left them without resolving the matter. He further referred to the state of the campus letter as was written by the union to the management of Dutywa campus and was not attended to by the management.
[121] He further submitted that lecturers requested catch up plan which was refused by the management and later management brought its own catch up plan, which was late and not applicable as it was during examination time. He confirmed that it was the management that has a right to bring catch up plan to the lecturers, but lecturers may propose catch up plan to the management. He further confirmed that catch up plan cannot be allowed at the beginning of the year as teaching has not yet started.
[122] He disputed during cross examination that there were union members that were coming to the campus to sign and go to sit under the tree, as his members were teaching in classes.
[123] He stated that during the time of other managers, management was better than the time of Mr Potelwa as he brought changes that affected employees and were not accepted, so he supported the union view in their letter.
[124] He confirmed that they changed their representative, Dumisa Bongo in the hearing as he recused himself for his personal reasons and they appointed a shop steward to represent the applicant.

[125] Witness 5 Siyabonga Khumalo
[126] He testified that he was the lecturer of the respondent and knew the applicant as former lecturer of the respondent charged and dismissed for not invigilating November 2022 examinations. He stated that lecturers are not allowed to attend invigilation and marking when they have not fulfilled the requirements of finishing marking, invigilated examinations, submitted marks and be released by the management.
[127] He stated that an invigilator is appointed when he has applied for marking and be appointed to mark that particular paper.
[128] He stated that there are two forms of invigilation being external and internal invigilation. He described internal examination as invigilation where a lecturer set paper, assess students, mark scripts and be invigilated by a colleague as inherent job description of a lecturer which will not be paid by the employer and external invigilation is when lecturer has been appointed to invigilate external paper and be paid for such invigilation.
[129] He submitted that the applicant did not invigilate November 2022 examinations as the matter was still under discussion and not yet resolved, so they decided not to invigilate examinations as lecturers and not only applicant not invigilated the examinations, but all lecturers did not invigilate November 2022 examinations.
[130] He stated that as fifteen lecturers participated in not invigilating November 2022 examinations, but only eight lecturers were charged and dismissed as others were not charged at all with no reason for not charging others.
[131] He referred to the meeting that was for the staff and management where he stated that tempos were high as staff were raising their concerns to the management to such that the applicant managed to control the meeting and he disputed that the applicant humiliated Ms Mayekiso as it did not happen and or be reported to them.
[132] He further referred to the government gazette where he stated that according to the gazette lecturers are supposed to be remunerated for invigilation.
[133] He confirmed that the applicant was charged with all the charges listed in the charge sheet, but can’t confirm that she breached the rules of the respondent.
[134] He emphasised during cross examination that the decision not to collect their invigilation letters and invigilate was the decision of all lecturers and not a decision of the union.
[135] He disputed that the resolution not to invigilate was of a particular union as lecturers belong to different unions in the campus, so all unions participated in the resolution not to invigilate
[136] He confirmed that the applicant taught students at the beginning of the year as she further marked supplementary papers in March 2023, but emphasised that as registration delayed teaching to start late, many lecturers did not complete their work and catch up plan was issued, although it was late to complete their term work as other lectures did not participate in April 2023 catch up plan as they viewed that it was designed to frustrate them during examination period, so he stated that no lecturers participated in April 2023 catch up plan brought by the management and further disputed that there were seven lecturers that participated in the catch up plan. He further confirmed that the management is responsible to bring catch up plan when syllabus is not completed by lecturers for known reason like delayed registration and strikes.
[137] He further emphasised that remuneration of invigilators is paid to the external invigilators as papers are set externally.
[138] He stated during re-examination that there was no charge on catch up by lecturers and there was no charge related to the year 2023 in the charges against the applicant..

ANALYSIS OF EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENT
[139] In terms of section 185 of the Labour Relations Act, 1995 as amended (“the Act / the LRA”) every employee has the right not to be unfairly dismissed. Section 192 of the LRA provides that the employee carries the onus of proving the existence of a dismissal, whilst the employer has to prove that dismissal was fair.
[140] In the present case, it was common cause that the Applicant was dismissed. She challenged the procedural and substantive fairness of her dismissal and therefore the
onus rests on the Respondent to prove the fairness of the dismissal of the Applicant on a balance of probabilities and start leading evidence in this arbitration.
[141] In this case the Applicant was charged and dismissed for failure to carry out a lawful order or routine instruction without just or reasonable cause in that she was reasonably instructed to collect appointment letters or on about 28 -31 October 2022, failed to invigilate November 2022 examinations which is inherent to lecturer’s job description as per the policies, she performed poorly or inadequately for reasons other than incapacity in that she failed to teach and cover syllabus for the classes and or students that were allocated to her, which compromised teaching and learning for those affected students, she conducting staff meeting that was not authorised by the campus management, She incited other personnel to unprocedural and unlawful conduct in that in one meeting she started humiliating Ms Mayekiso and further incited other members to see the campus leadership as incompetent and or inefficient.
[142] Considering procedural fairness that the union was not consulted and engaged as applicant was a shop steward, l find that the respondent failed to consult and inform the union that the applicant was charged as she was a shop steward known to the respondent as they confirmed to receive the letter from NEHAWU informing that the applicant was an additional member of the campus executive committee and further had various meetings with the applicant as shop steward of the union as testified by Mr Ntlangano, applicant, Mayekiso and Mrwetyana . In the case of Avril Elizabeth Home for Mentally Handicapped v CCMA and Others [2006] 27 IJL (LC) the court held that the employer was merely required to conduct an investigation, give an employee an opportunity to prepare to respond to the allegations after a reasonable period and thereafter to take decision and give an employee notice thereof. In this case l find that the applicant was a shop steward and her union was never been
informed of charges laid against the applicant by the respondent. According to Schedule 8 item 4 (2) of the LRA discipline against a trade union representative or an employee who is an office bearer or official of a trade union should not be instituted without first informing and consulting the trade union. In this case the union was never been informed and consulted before instituting charges against the applicant.
[143] Considering substantive fairness on testimonies of the parties to the charges of failure to follow a reasonable and lawful instruction to collect invigilation letters to invigilate and to invigilate November 2022 examinations, l find that the Applicant did breach the rule as she admitted and corroborated by all witnesses testified in this case that the applicant did not collect invigilation letters and invigilate 2022 examinations.
[144] Considering failure to teach and cover syllabus for the classes and or students that are allocated to her, which compromised teaching and learning for the affected students, l find that the applicant did not breach the rule as she taught student after registration and further requested catch up classes, which was refused as teaching not fully started as testified by the applicant and corroborated by Mr Ntlangano, Ms Magwaca, Mr Mrwetyana, Ms Mabentsela and Mr Khumalo. I further find that all lecturers failed to finish their syllabus due to challenges encountered during opening of the campus in January like delayed registration, strikes and late students entries to the various lecturers as testified by the applicant and corroborated by Mr Ntlangano, Mayekiso, Mabentsela and Mr Potelwa. So, in my view all lecturers failed to complete their term work that resulted into extending teaching and learning time through catch up organised in April, but not attended by fifteen lecturers involved in invigilation incident as some lecturers were not charged and dismissed as testified by the applicant, Mr Potelwa, Ms Magwaca and Mr Khumalo. Therefore, l view that it was inappropriate to charge and sanction the applicant under the mentioned circumstances that include inconsistency as other lecturers were not charged as testified by the applicant, Mr Khumalo, Ms Mabentsela and Ms Mpehle.
I further consider an issue of inconsistency to the issue of failure to collect letters of invigilation, issue of not invigilating of the applicant and not finalising teaching and tasks, I find that fifteen lecturers that were involved in not collecting invigilation letters and invigilate November 2022 examinations and lecturers not completed their syllabus were selectively charged, as only eight lecturers charged and seven lecturers not charged by the respondent, although they all simultaneously committed similar offence as testified by Mr Potelwa and corroborated by Ms Magwaca, Applicant, Mabentsela and Mrwetyana. Based on this inconsistency, I conclude that the applicant was not treated similarly with other seven lecturers that were not charged and dismissed, so there is no charge and sanction against her like other seven lecturers that were not charged and dismissed. In Early Bird Farms (Pty) Ltd v Mlambo [1997] 5 BLLR 541 (LAC) the court held that like cases should be treated alike, as further confirmed in the Labour Relations Act of 1995 Schedule 8 on of the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal item 3(6) that the parity principle requires employers to apply discipline consistently for similar misconduct. Based on inconsistency, l conclude that the applicant not to have been charged and sanctioned like other lecturers not charged and dismissed.
[145] Considering the charge of conducting an unauthorised staff meeting, l find that the meeting was authorised by Mr Potelwa who was the campus manager as per his testimony that he engaged the applicant to amend the agenda, to chair the meeting and attended the meeting he granted permission to proceed as was corroborated by the applicant and Ms Magwaca. I reject evidence that the meeting was not authorised as was not chaired by Mr Potelwa and applicant not amended the agenda, as the meeting was chaired by the applicant.
Considering charge of inciting other personnel to not procedural and unlawful conduct that in one of the meetings the applicant took a podium and humiliated Ms Mayekiso and other members of the management as incompetent, l find that the applicant did not breach the rule as she disputed humiliating management as she was chairing a hot meeting of the complaints of the staff to the management, where the applicant had to manage and control such meeting with consequences that some management members were angry to the extent of voicing unacceptable words, which she advised them to withdraw through the control of the meeting as testified by the applicant, Mr Khumalo and Ms Magwaca. So, l find that words of incompetent as testified by Mr Potelwa was disputed by the applicant and not corroborated by any evidence including words of Ms Mayekiso that she was unprofessional and evidence of Ms Magwaca that the applicant was pointing fingers to the management were disputed by the applicant and not corroborated by any further evidence that the applicant humiliating the management in the meeting. In conclusion, l find the applicant that she did not humiliate management, but she was in the pressure of the meeting especially to advise the manager to withdraw some words in the meeting as was chairing the meeting. I further view these different forms of alleged humiliation as afterthought since each manager was stating his or her own view of humiliation with no corroboration of one another.
[146] Considering all the above, l find that the sanction of dismissal by the Respondent to the Applicant was inappropriate and unfair, as confirmed by the court in the case of Vodacom (Pty) Ltd v Byrne NO and Others (2012) 33 IJL (LC), the Court held that the determination of fairness of dismissal required a Commissioner to form value judgment by having regard to the interest of both parties to achieve a balance and equitable assessment of the fairness of the sanction.
[147] I therefore, find from the above evidence that the applicant’s evidence outweighs evidence of the respondent and the Respondent has not successfully discharged onus on a balance of probabilities to prove that the dismissal was procedurally and substantively fair.
[148] Considering the remedy as in terms of section 193 of the LRA on failure of the respondent to consult and engage the union NEHAWU prior to instituting charges against the applicant, l find that the applicant must be compensated by the respondent for one month of her gross salary prior to dismissal being R31397-38.
[149] I further direct that the respondent must reinstate the applicant to her post of being a lecturer at Dutywa campus in similar terms and conditions of her original employment post prior to her dismissal with no back. This decision of reinstating the applicant with no back pay is based on considering the applicant as the shop steward, which l believe she was aware of the procedures to be engaged in a strike action in terms of the section 64 of the LRA, which l view she had not followed, being involved in not invigilating November 2022 examination, but saved by inconsistency, which l view not to be praised by back pay.

AWARD
[150] The Applicant Ntombebele Zothani’s dismissal by the Department of Higher Education and Training King Hintsa TVET College was procedurally and substantively unfair.
[151] The Applicant’s application for unfair dismissal is granted.
[152] The respondent is ordered to pay the applicant Ntombebele Zothani an amount of R31397-38 (Thirty One Thousand Three Hundred and Ninety Seven Rand Thirty Eight Cents) on or before 28 February 2027 as compensation for failure to consult union prior to instituting charge against the applicant.
[153] The applicant is ordered to report at King Hintsa Tvet College, Dutywa campus on 23 November 2026 of being aware of this award.

ELRC Panellist
Bongani Mtati