IN THE EDUCATION LABOUR RELATIONS COUNCIL
In the INQUIRY BY ARBITRATOR between
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCTION – GAUTENG PROVINCE “the Employer”
AND
E ZUNGUZA “the Employee”
SECTION 188A INQUIRY BY ARBITRATOR RULING
CASE NUMBER: ELRC77 – 26/27GP
DATE AWARD SUBMITTED: 12 November 2026
NAME OF COMMISSIONER: Coen Havenga
Details of hearing and representation
- This process was set down in terms of section 188A of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 as amended (hereafter “the LRA”), and ELRC Collective Agreement 3 of 2018. The matter was heard on several days and the last day of the inquiry took place on 30 September 2026 at the offices of the Employer in Norwood. The parties requested opportunity to submit written closing arguments which were duly received and form part of the record.
- The Employer is the Gauteng Department of Education, represented by Ms Morena, M. The accused Employee is Mr Zunguza, E, (“Zunguza”), represented by Mr PG Masindi, an advocate, following a successful unopposed application for legal representation.
- Ms Nghonyama, I, acted as interpreter, and the intermediary was Ms Wentzel, G.
Issue to be decided
- I am required to determine whether Zunguza is guilty of the charges levelled against him. Should I find him guilty of the charges, then I need to determine the appropriate sanction, as well as make a determination in terms of section 120(1)(c) of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005 whether Zunguza is unsuitable to work with children.
Background and charges
- Zunguza, an educator employed at Ivory Park Secondary School (“the School”), is charged with one allegation of misconduct.
- Charge 1 – charged with misconduct in terms of section 17(1)(b) of the Employment of Educators Act 76 of 1998. It is alleged that on or around 25 December 2025 he sexually assaulted a grade 12 learner (hereinafter referred to as “the Complainant”) of Ivory Park Secondary School.
- The parties conducted a pre-arbitration meeting, the signed minutes had been submitted and will form part of the record. The Employer also submitted a bundle of documents marked as Bundle A, and a voice recording.
- The parties agreed that Zunguza is employed as Departmental Head at Ivory Park Secondary School. He taught grade 10 and 11 mathematics and grade 11 and 12 accounting.
Plea
- Zunguza pleaded not guilty to charge 1 and denied all the allegations against him.
Summary of evidence
- The proceedings have been recorded digitally, and a summary of the Employer’s and Employee’s witnesses’ evidence follows below. What follows is only a summary of the evidence deduced at the arbitration hearing and does not purport to be a verbatim transcription of all the testimony given. The digital record of the proceedings will reflect the complete testimony of the witnesses. The fact that I have not captured all of it herein should not be misconstrued that I have not taken all the evidence presented into account. My findings are, accordingly, within the context of all the evidence provided by the parties during the arbitration hearing.
- The matter relates to, inter alia, allegations of sexual misconduct towards a learner who was a minor at the time of the alleged incidents. In accordance with the protection of the rights of minors afforded them in the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, the identity of that learner and other minor witnesses will not be disclosed. I will refer to the minor witness for the Employer as the Complainant. The witness testified from a separate room via MS Teams virtual platform, with the assistance of an interpreter and an intermediary.
Employer’s case
- Yvonne Mathinya (“Mathinya”) testified under oath that she is the mother of the Complainant. On 3 March 2026 she went to the School after she heard that the Complainant said that she was raped by the educator. She asked to see the principal, her child and the educator, whom she knew.
- The Complainant came and they entered the principal’s office. Ms Mamabolo also came. They gave her a form 22 to complete. She told the principal why she was there and asked to see the educator. She wanted him to tell her what had happened.
- The principal called the educator, and he came to the office. The principal wanted to introduce them, but she told the principal that they already knew each other.
- She asked him whether he was in a relationship with her child. He said they were not in a relationship. She told them that she heard that he raped her and asked him how it happened. He started by saying it was a mistake and that he was sorry. He said he did not do it intentionally. He said it came to a point where he and her child had sex.
- He said the child would vent towards him when she had family problems, and that they were close for that reason. She said to him that her child told her he had raped her.
- While they were talking, the Employee stood up and asked the principal and Ms Mamabolo to go outside as he wanted to talk to Mathinya alone. The Employee told the principal that it would be safe to leave them alone.
- When they left the Employee stood up, came to her and kneeled in front of her, he told her he was sorry and asked her to forgive him. She told him it would be the child’s decision to forgive him, not hers. She asked him if he used a condom, and he said he did not. She asked him about his HIV status, and he said he did a test in November 2025 and held up his phone as to prove it. She asked him whether he was not going to infect her child or make her pregnant, and he said he knew his status. He told her that the child was not pregnant as she had her menstrual period since, which meant that they were still communicating.
- She told him that she would talk to her child and update him. The principal came back and she told her what happened. The principal asked her whether she could find it in her heart to forgive him. She told the principal that he did not respect her by having sex with her child.
- She left with the Complainant. She asked her why she only reported it then when it happened in December 2025. She said the Employee pleaded with her not to tell anyone, but it was bothering her now. She felt that she was forced to have sex with him and that she had to open a case.
- The Complainant knew the address where the rape took place, so they went to Norkem Park SAPS to lay a charge. The Complainant reported it to her private maths tutor, who reported it to Mathinya. They made statements.
- At the SAPS the Employee called her while she was in the parking. He asked her what he should do. He continued to apologise and to ask her to forgive him. He wanted to come to her house to ask for forgiveness. She told him that it was not her decision and hung up.
- After opening the case she took the Complainant to the trauma centre at Tembisa Hospital. While she waited outside the Employee called her again, she said she could not forgive him and ended the call. Then a person by the name of Bongani called her and told her he was the brother of the Employee. He told her his brother made a mistake and asked for their forgiveness for the mistake of him having sex with the child. She told him she could not forgive his brother. He said that they would do anything for them not to open a case. He asked if they could meet as families, but she ended the call.
- The following day she worked night shift. The Complainant called her and told her she had a missed call from someone. They checked the number and she saw it was Bongani’s number. After about an hour the Complainant sent her a long recording of a conversation with Bongani. In short, he continued to ask for his brother to be forgiven and that they could give her anything not to continue with the case, as his brother’s future was on the line.
- Mathinya called the Employee and told him to tell Bongani to stop calling her child. He said that he was not aware that Bongani was calling them. He undertook to tell Bongani to stop. He then also continued to ask for forgiveness.
- About two days later Bongani called Mathinya again and asked to meet her. She called the Employee before that as the police wanted to arrest him and could not find him. She called him to arrange a meeting so that the police could arrest him. The investigating officer (IO) said she must agree to meet so they could arrest him. She arranged a meeting with the Employee. He said he would let her know the time of the meeting. Then Bongani called her again and said he heard they agreed to meet.
- He sent her a location in Birchleigh. She found Bongani there. He sent another location where the Employee joined them at a garage. She agreed to go to their house. They went in three cars. They parked their cars inside and suggested that she park outside. She refused and sent the location to the IO. She went inside the yard on foot and entered the house.
- They sat on a couch. She asked them why they called her there in order to buy time for the police to arrive. Bongani said they wanted to talk about the Employee’s matter. She suggested that she hear from the Employee. The Employee said sorry mama, he was tempted by her child and he asked for forgiveness. He said they could do anything she wanted.
- The Employee said they could even pay money. In the recorded conversation with the Complainant Bongani offered her R100 000,00 to save the Employee’s job, as it was the only thing he knew.
- Bongani told Mathinya if the R100 000,00 was too little, she should tell him how much she wanted. She told him it was not about money.
- The Employee went to the bathroom, and the police were outside. He was then arrested. A18 reflects the number on which Bongani called her. It is his picture that appears there.
- During-cross-examination Mathinya testified that the private tutor first informed her. She was working in Limpopo. The Complainant was 17 years old when it happened.
- She is a police officer. She did not wear her uniform when she confronted the Employee in the office. Her firearm was locked away in the safe before she went into the principal’s office.
- The Complainant was part of a group of top learners which the Employee gave extra classes to. It is not true that the Employee only saw her at school. The Complainant took a picture at the Employee’s place, and she took Mathinya to his place of residence after she went to the school. Mathinya was not aware that the Complainant continued to be part of the Employee’s top group. She realised they were still close when the Employee told her that he knew she had her menstrual period.
- The Employee did admit to her that he had sex with the Complainant, and they talked about HIV, condoms and pregnancy. She did not insist that he resign. She did not threaten him with law enforcement if he did not resign. The recording is proof of the money that was offered. She was there in her capacity as parent, not as a police officer.
- Bongani said the Employee sent him to ask for forgiveness on his behalf. He stated that in the recorded conversation. She called the Employee after she listened to the recoding, and he said that he was not aware that Bongani phoned the child, that he was sorry and that he would ask Bongani not to do it again.
- She assumed it was Bongani’s house where they met, as he arranged the meeting.
- The Complainant, currently an 18-year-old female learner who was in grade 11 in the School in 2025, testified under oath via MS Teams with the assistance of an intermediary. She was part of the Employee’s maths achievers’ group in 2025.
- There was a Whatsapp group where the Employee got her number from. The employee began talking to her privately on Whatsapp. They talked about her father’s unveiling, and he wanted to know who she went with. She told him that she did not have a close relationship with her mother. She told him about her problems at home, and he motivated her. She told him she once attempted suicide. That was when he started to check on her every day.
- When other learners put questions on the Whatsapp group, he responded on the group. When she put a question on the group, he responded to her Whatsapp directly.
- During the school holidays on 24 December 2025, he asked to see her. She agreed and he came to see her at about 20:00. He said he knew where she stayed. He came and they walked and sat in an open area close to her home. He then took her home.
- On 25 December 2025 he messaged her again. She met him outside again and she got into his car. They went to where he stayed. He opened the gate and put the car in the garage. He closed the gate. They went inside to the sitting room. He left her and she sat on the table and looked at some papers.
- The Employee came in and started to touch her. She told him that she did not want to, but he continued to forcefully touch her and took off her dress. He then raped her. He stopped when his phone rang. He told her it was his brother calling. He told her that she was lucky because his brother asked him to go and fetch him. She got dressed and he took her home.
- On the way home she asked him why he did that to her and was he not afraid that she will tell people. He said nobody would believe her. He dropped her at her house. She did tell her friend what happened.
- In January 2025 when the school opened, she met him at school, and he tried to touch her. She refused. He said they should go into the toilet, but she refused and went to class. She did ask him questions about maths as time went by. He continued to want to touch her when he came across her on the stairs. That is what made her to report him, as she could see he would not stop what he was doing.
- She did ask him for help with maths as she felt there was nobody else that could help her.
- Bongani, the Employee’s brother, called her and said she should not open a case because the Employee made a mistake and he was sorry. They were willing to give her R100 000,00 not to open a case. She recorded the conversation with Bongani.
- At school she reported the incident to the HOD of Life Orientation, Ms Mamabolo. She told sister Nancy at school and asked her to tell her mother as she was afraid to tell her. Her mother came to school, and they went to the principal’s office. Her mother wanted to talk to the Employee. She was not part of the conversation.
- Before the Employee raped her, he was a person she could talk to, that is why she felt comfortable around him.
- During cross-examination the Complainant testified that Bongani introduced himself when he called her, and said he wanted to apologise on behalf of his brother. He offered her money, but she declined it. She sent the recording to her mother and the Employer’s representative. Bongani did not say he was sent by the Employee.
- She told her friend and her maths tutor about the rape. The Employee treated her differently when she came late after she reported the matter. He no longer beat her as he did with the other learners and with her before. The Employee did rape her.
- She did not report the case immediately after informing her friend because she hoped that it would not happen again, and she was embarrassed people would ask a lot of questions about why she went with him to his house. It was all confusing to her at the time that it happened. Her heart was already broken, and she did not want to experience more pain. She was traumatised. She did not fabricate the rape.
Employee’s case
- Edward Zunguza, the Employee, testified under oath that in 2025 he created a top achiever group for extra tutoring which included the Complainant. He did not teach her in normal classes.
- He did not meet with her in December 2025 at all. He never met her outside the school premises. He only saw her again when school opened in 2025. She would come to his office to ask questions occasionally after school started. Sometimes she asked him questions on his private Whatsapp.
- They had a teacher/learner relationship. The last week before her mother came to school he noticed she came late often. He was surprised by her attitude. He asked her what was wrong and she said nothing was wrong.
- He did not meet her on 24 December 2025. He left Nelspruit at 18:00 and arrived at his place at 23:00. He did not meet her on 25 December 2025. On that day he went to Ivory Park with family, then to Tembisa until 04:00 on 26 December 2025 at a place called Majozi. He never fetched her and he never saw her on 25 December 2025. She does not know where he stays. He did not meet her at school and asked her to go to the bathroom with him.
- The testimony of Mathinya that he told her that the child could not be pregnant because she told him she had her period, is correct. That is what the child said when she did badly in a test. He did not have sex with her. He never apologised to her mother.
- During cross-examination the Employee testified that he did ask the mother to exchange numbers as he wanted to know what decision she took. He just wanted to know which direction they were going. He did not rape the Complainant.
- Bongani is not his brother, but he knew him. Lucky is his brother. He did not know where Bongani got her number. He knew Bongani called her when she was with Lucky. He did not give Bongani the numbers. He did not put it to the witnesses that Bongani was not his brother because that is what Bongani claimed. He did not challenge the evidence of Mathinya about him asking for forgiveness, and that he did not use a condom and that he was HIV negative specifically because it did not happen.
- He did meet with Bongani and Mathinya on the day of his arrest. Mathinya called him and said they spoke to Bongani. He called his brother Lucky to inform him. Lucky said he would call Bongani, they then sent him a location to a garage.
- He agreed that he did not put his version that he was in Nelspruit to the Complainant. He did not put most of his version to the witnesses because he did not know he had to.
Summary of arguments
- Both parties submitted extensive written closing arguments which form part of the record and will not be repeated here. The parties were directed to address the issues of guilt, appropriate sanction, should the Employee be found guilty, and his fitness to work with children, should he be found guilty. I have considered the arguments, together with the other evidence, oral and documentary, presented by the parties during the inquiry, as reflected in the record of the hearing.
Analysis of evidence and argument
- This inquiry was conducted in terms of the principles contained in section 188A, as well as Schedule 8 of the LRA, and ELRC Collective Agreement 3 of 2018, in respect of the fairness of disciplinary action against educators charged with sexual misconduct in respect of learners. In applying those principles, the following factors were considered:
a) Whether or not the accused employee contravened a rule or standard regulating conduct in, or of relevance to, the workplace; and
b) If the rule or standard was contravened, whether or not –
i. The rule was a valid or reasonable rule or standard;
ii. The accused employee was aware, or could reasonably be expected to have been aware, of the rule or standard;
iii. The employer has consistently applied the rule or standard.
iv. Dismissal would be an appropriate sanction for the contravention of the rule or standard.
- The LRA does not prescribe the standard of proof to be used in labour matters. It is however universally accepted that the standard of proof that is applicable in disciplinary hearings, and therefore inquiries by arbitrators of this nature is identical to the civil standard – “the employer must prove the case against the employee on the balance of probabilities and not beyond reasonable doubt” – Meadow Feeds (Pietermaritzburg) vs. Sweet Food and Allied Workers Union (1998) Arb1.2.1.
- All the allegations in the charge against the Employee, as well as the evidence, documentary and otherwise, deduced in support thereof by the Employer, and the evidence deduced by the Employee in defence, were considered and weighed against the abovementioned standard of proof.
- It is not disputed by the Employee that the actions he had been charged with constitute misconduct. He merely denied committing the alleged misconduct as set out in the charge below.
- Charge 1 – charged with misconduct in terms of section 17(1)(b) of the Employment of Educators Act 76 of 1998. It is alleged that on or around 25 December 2025 he sexually assaulted a grade 12 learner (hereinafter referred to as “the Complainant”) of Ivory Park Secondary School.
- I am mindful of the fact that the Employee is charged with sexual misconduct. It is a natural response in matters relating to the sexual assault that the reasonable person might view such conduct with disgust and revulsion. This is even more applicable where a trust relationship is abused. As arbitrator one should however be conscious of the need not to prejudge but to objectively consider the facts of the matter on a balance of probabilities and credibility of the evidence adduced.
- In respect of all the allegations the Employee disputes any wrongdoing, and I must decide on a balance of probabilities which version to accept.
- The Employee’s defence in respect of the alleged sexual assault is a blanket denial of any wrongdoing. He submits that it is all a fabrication of lies.
- I take cognisance of the fact that the Complainant is a single witness in respect of what allegedly transpired in the presence of the Employee. It is also important to remember that this is an arbitration hearing, and the matter needs to be dealt with the minimum of legal formalities, as it is not a criminal trial. Even if the rule is not applicable in civil proceedings or arbitration proceedings, I must nevertheless be satisfied that the evidence of a single witness is reliable and trustworthy before relying on it.
- It must be remembered that the Complainant was only seventeen years old at the time of the incidents, and that the incidents took place during December 2025, while the arbitration hearing only commenced in July 2026. Naturally, the lapse of time would affect the memories of witnesses, and I assessed the evidence against this backdrop.
- It has been shown that children who are sexually abused, concentrate on the core details of the incident and not so much on peripheral details. The omission of peripheral details like dates, or contradiction relating thereto, is not usually a basis for rejecting the testimony of a child witness. What is most important is consistency regarding the core details of the experience. Refer to the ELRC Guidelines: Inquiries by ELRC arbitrators in terms of section 188A of the LRA relating to misconduct of a sexual nature in respect of learners.
- The Constitutional Court has held that that the sexual assault of children has the inherent effect of rendering child victims unable to report the incident, sometimes for several decades, and that they should not be penalised for the consequences of their abuse by blaming them for the delay. The Courts have accepted that feelings of fear and shame often prevent children from reporting such incidents immediately and that the victims often distance themselves from reality and transfer responsibility onto themselves. In 2007 the law was amended to provide that no inference may be drawn from the length of any delay between the alleged commission of such offence and the reporting thereof. The fact that a child does not tell another teacher at school about an incident that occurred at school but only tells a parent or grandparent later at home, or visa versa, is therefore no indication that the child has fabricated the evidence. Sometimes children would, due to feelings of shame, not tell a parent or teacher, but rather tell a close friend.
- The above is aptly relevant in this case where the Complainant did not immediately report the incident to her mother or to other educators at school. I reject the arguments of the Employee that the fact that she did not mention it earlier tarnishes the credibility of her evidence in any material way. The very nature of the alleged sexual intercourse is such that she would not have had any bystanders that could testify about the sexual intercourse. I will consider her viva voce evidence in respect of the merits and credibility of her version of the events.
- I find no material discrepancies or inconsistencies in the evidence of the Complainant that would negatively affect her credibility. I find the Employee’s version of a blanket denial and that the Complainant fabricated the rape allegations, improbable. He could not substantiate his version with any probable proof. The Employee never put this version of having an alibi by being in Nelspruit to any of the witnesses. He never disputed in cross-examination the evidence that Bongani called the mother and child, and that he presented himself as the brother of the Employee that offered R100 000,00 for the child’s forgiveness. Only in his evidence in chief that he mentioned that Bongani was not his brother. This is a material aspect of this case in relation to probability of the Complainant’s version that the Employee raped her.
- In NUM and another v CCMA and others [2018] 3 BLLR 267 (LAC) the Court found that since key aspects of the employee’s case were not put to the employer’s witnesses in cross-examination and had not been canvassed in the evidence of those witnesses in chief, their version on such aspects was not placed before the commissioner. The same principle will therefore apply in this matter.
- I find on a balance of probabilities that Bongani did call the Complainant and her mother in his stated capacity as the brother of the Employee to beg for forgiveness on his behalf and to offer the amount of R100 000,00 for them not to make a case against the Employee. The only probable reason why Bongani would have made such a call and offer was because the Employee did in fact rape the Complainant. There would have been no reason to make such a call if the Employee did nothing wrong. Despite her young age, the Complainant stood steadfast by her version. She described the events leading up to as well as the rape in graphic detail, as well as the fact that the Employee was interrupted by his brother’s call. I find it highly improbable that the Complainant fabricated such a version.
- The Employee’s case relied heavily on the fact that he did not ask his brother or Bongani to call the Complainant and her mother, and on his visit to family as his alibi. However, the Employee did not call anyone to testify and corroborate his version. The Employee gave no reason for not calling his brother Lucky, Bongani or any other family member who could verify his alibi. I have no option but to attach a negative inference to his failure to call those witnesses to corroborate his version.
- The court in the case of the Bargaining Council for Furniture Manufacturing Industry, Kwazulu- Natal v UKD Marketing CC and Others (2013) 34 ILJ 96 (LAC) stated that an adverse inference should be drawn from a party’s failure to call a witness that could prove his or her version more probable.
- In Munster Estates (Pty) Ltd v Killarney Hills (Pty) Ltd, 1979(1) SA 621 AD the Appeal Court held that where a party fails to call as his witness one who is available and able to elucidate the facts, the inference that the party failed to call such a person as a witness because he feared that such evidence would expose facts unfavourable to him should be drawn.
- In Tshishonga v Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development and Another, (JS898/04) (2007) (4) SA 135 (LC) the Labour Court held that an adverse inference must be drawn if a party fails to place evidence of a witness who is available and able to elucidate the facts as this failure leads naturally to the inference that he fears that such evidence will expose facts unfavourable to him or even damage his case.
- I find the Employee’s version that the Complainant decided to falsely accuse him of rape for no reason highly improbable.
- The risk of false incrimination in sexual cases is addressed in Hoffman and Zeffert, The South African Law of Evidence, 4th Edition, Butterworths, 1992, as follows: “Corroboration is the most satisfactory indication that the Complainant is truthful, but false evidence by the accused or his failure to testify may also be taken into account, as may any other feature of the case which shows that the Complainant’s evidence is reliable and that of the accused false.”. The Complainant’s version has been materially the same throughout the inquiry. I find it improbable that she would make up such a detailed version of events without any reason. The Employee’s version that it is a fabrication is not plausible.
- The Complainant testified to the forced sexual intercourse and penetration that took place between her and the Employee, an educator in the School where she was a learner.
- Therefore, with consideration of all the relevant cautionary rules I find that the Employer provided evidence that proves on a balance of probabilities that the Employee committed the misconduct as contained in charges 1, i.e. sexual assault. There is therefore evidence before me that proves that the Employee contravened a rule or standard regulating conduct in, or of relevance to, the workplace.
Finding
87. The accused employee, Mr Zunguza, E, is found guilty of the following misconduct:
- Charge 1 – contravention of section 17(1)(b) of the Employment of Educators Act 76 of 1998, in that on or around 25 December 2025 he sexually assaulted a grade 12 learner (hereinafter referred to as “the Complainant”) of Ivory Park Secondary School.
Sanction
- In considering an appropriate sanction, I am required to exercise my discretion reasonably, honestly and with due regard to the general principles of fairness.
- Zunguza’s conduct is in direct contravention of the values and obligations prescribed by The Code of Professional Ethics of Educators. He failed to act in a proper and becoming way so that his behaviour does not bring the teaching profession into disrepute. The Code places emphasis on educators refraining from any form of sexual assault on learners and not abusing the position he holds for personal gain. Section 28(2) of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 108 of 1996 provides that a child’s best interests are of paramount importance in every matter concerning the child. This is a factor that I keep in mind as, surely, it was not in the best interest of the Complainant being a minor female learner to be sexually assaulted by an educator.
- Section 17(1) of the EEA states that dismissal is the mandatory sanction for the misconduct of sexually assaulting a learner, which I keep in mind considering the nature of Zunguza’s misconduct.
- Having considered all the facts before me, including but not limited to, the gravity of the offences, the position of trust the Employee was employed in, and the years of service of the Employee, I find that the sanction of summary dismissal is fair and appropriate in the circumstances.
Sanction - In terms of section 188A(9) of the LRA I direct that the employee, Mr Zunguza, E, be dismissed summarily on receipt of this award.
Finding in respect of section 120 of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005
94. Section 120(1)(c) of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005 (“the Act”) provides that a finding that a person is unsuitable to work with children may be made by “any forum established or recognized by law in any disciplinary proceedings concerning the conduct of that person relating to a child”. Section 120(2) of the Act provides that a finding that a person is unsuitable to work with children may be made by such a forum on its own volition or on application by an organ of state or any other person having sufficient interest in the protection of children. The arbitrator may also make the finding on his/her own accord.
- The parties were given the opportunity to submit arguments in this respect. I have considered both parties’ submissions. In view of my finding of the serious nature of the Employee, Mr Zunguza’s conduct and the priority to protect the rights of children, I find that he is unsuitable to work with children. The fact that there are no previous incidents on record, does not necessarily mean that his conduct will not be repeated. In tribunals of this nature, consideration of the best interests of children, is paramount. My finding is aimed at the protection of children and in particular in this case, vulnerable young girls.
- Mr Zunguza, E, is found unsuitable to work with children in terms of section 120(4) of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005. The General Secretary of the ELRC must, in terms of section 122(1) of the Act, notify the Director General: Department of Social Development in writing of the findings of this forum made in terms of section 120(4) of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005, that Mr Zunguza, E, is unsuitable to work with children, for the Director General to enter his name as contemplated in section 120 in part B of the register.
COEN HAVENGA
Senior ELRC Arbitrator
12 November 2026

