View Categories

19 November 2026 – ELRC630-26/27GP

IN THE EDUCATION LABOUR RELATIONS COUNCIL HELD AT MEYERSDAL
CASE NO.: ELRC630-26/27GP
In the matter between:-

DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION- GP EMPLOYER

AND

SONKE LESLEY NTSHANGASE EMPLOYEE

ARBITRATOR: Mmamahlola Gloria Rabyanyana
Heard: 21 October 2026
Closing Arguments: 28 October 2026
Aggravating Factors: 28 October 2026
Date of Award: 18 November 2026
SUMMARY: Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 –Section 188A: Enquiry by Arbitrator.

Award





DETAILS OF HEARING AND REPRESENTATION

  1. The inquiry by the arbitrator was held physically at the Department of Education’s Ekurhuleni South District offices in Meyersdal on 21 October 2026. Mr. R. Mabandla, its Labour Relations Official, represented the employer. The educator, Mr Sonke Ntshangase, was absent. I requested Mr Mogotsi, the Council’s case management officer, to establish Mr Ntshangase’s whereabouts.
  2. The feedback from Mr. Mogotsi was that when he called the educator several times, the phone rang a few times and then ended. Mr Mabandla submitted that the educator was on a precautionary transfer and was supposed to report at the Circuit Manager’s offices from 10 September 2026. Mr Ntshangase never reported for work at the offices.
  3. His calls to the educator on 17 and 29 September 2026 were unsuccessful. He was following up on the pre-hearing meeting scheduled for 09 October 2026, which Mr Ntshangase failed to attend. His emails to the educator remained unanswered.
  4. Mr Bogopa, the school’s principal, submitted that his numerous efforts to track the educator have been fruitless until the educator called him on 03 October 2026. Mr Ntshangase informed him that he was in KZN, would not be returning to Gauteng, and was not interested in attending this inquiry.
  5. In light of Messers Mabandla and Bogopa’s submissions, which corroborate Mr Mogorosi’s call, I was satisfied that Mr Ntshangase waived his right to be heard. I proceeded in his absence.
  6. In Foschini Group v Maidi and Others (2010) 31 ILJ 1787 (LAC), the court held that ‘it is trite law that a party who chooses not to attend a hearing does so at his or her own peril and is precluded from later complaining about the outcome of the hearing.
  7. I recorded the proceedings digitally. The Employer’s bundle of documents is marked “R”. The Employer submitted closing arguments and aggravating factors on 23 October 2026.
    ISSUE TO BE DECIDED
  8. I am required to determine if the Employee had sexually harassed a learner as proffered by the Employer. If I find the Employee guilty of the offences, I will determine the appropriate sanction.

ALLEGATIONS PREFFERED AGAINST THE EMPLOYEE

  1. Mr Ntshangase was charged with three counts of misconduct as follows:- Allegation 1

It is alleged that on or around March 2026, he engaged in a sexual relationship with NM, a Grade 5 learner at Zimeleni LSEN School where he is employed.
In view of his actions, he is charged with misconduct in terms of Section
17 (1) (c) of the Employment of Educators Act 75 of 1998, as amended.

Allegation 2

It is alleged that on or around March 2026, while on duty as an educator at Zimelani LSEN School, he conducted himself in an improper, disgraceful and unacceptable manner in that he asked NM, a Grade 5 learner, to send him her nude pictures.
In view of your actions, you are thus charged with misconduct in terms of Section
18 (1) (q) of the Employment of Educators Act 75 of 1998, as amended.

Allegation 3

It is alleged that in or around March 2026, as an educator at Zimeleni LSEN School, he committed an act of sexual assault on a Grade 5 learner, NM, by kissing and hugging her in his classroom.:
In view of his actions, he was thus charged with misconduct in terms of Section
17 (1) (b) of the Employment of Educators Act 75 of 1998, as amended.

    EVALUATION AND SUMMARY OF EVIDENCE
  1. Mr Alfred Mafolo Bogopa testified that he is the Principal of the Zimeleni LSEN School (a school for learners with special needs). He received an anonymous phone call around June 2026. The caller enquired whether it is allowed for educators to have a sexual relationship with learners. He informed the caller that it was not allowed. He requested the caller to visit the school to provide details. However, the caller did not come.
  2. He later received a call from the parent of a learner at school. She informed him that she had discovered that Mr Ntshangase was in a relationship with her daughter, NM. He invited her to the school to lodge a formal complaint. He submitted the complaint to the district office. Mr. Ntshangase called and notified him that the police accused him of having a sexual relationship with a learner.
  3. Ms. NZ testified that she is NM’s mother. A learner from Zimeleni LSEN school informed her about the relationship between Mr. Ntshangase and NM. She checked NM’s phone for WhatsApp messages. She confirmed the NM’s nude video clips that she sent to Mr. Ntshangase. After NM had sent Mr Ntshangase her nude pictures, he sent pornographic videos. NM informed her that Mr Ntshangase requested her nude video clips.
  4. She feels bad and disappointed in Mr Ntshangase’s conduct towards NM. He took advantage of her daughter. It will take time for her to recover emotionally from this humiliation.
  5. NM testified that she was born on 09 March 2008 and is 18 years old. She is a Grade 5 learner at the school. I probed her understanding of the distinction between lies and truth and the importance of telling the truth.
  6. I established that she has a reasonable comprehension of fiction and reality. Furthermore, she could distinguish truth from lies. She could provide reasonable time estimates. She could fairly narrate the frequency of events, chronological order, and sequence of events. Therefore, I was satisfied that she was a competent witness. NM is a learner with special needs and a moderate intellectual disability. She required minimal assistance from the Intermediary.
  7. She confirmed that she had a relationship with Mr. Ntshangase. They were communicating through WhatsApp messages. Mr. Ntshangase had hugged and kissed her in his classroom on several occasions. He would call her to his classroom; sometimes she would go by herself.
  8. She sent her nude video clips to Mr. Ntshangase as he had requested. Mr Ntshangase informed her that she was yummy and sent her pornographic videos in return. He enquired with her if she was a virgin. When she confirmed that she was still a virgin, he instructed her to keep her virginity for him.
  9. No one influenced her to testify against Mr Ntshangase. Her testimony is a true reflection of what occurred between her and Mr Ntshangase. No one told her to create a story against Mr. Ntshangase.

Closing Arguments

  1. The employer’s representative argued that Mr. Ntshangase’s absence was calculated to avoid embarrassment, as he had no alibi to refute the allegations. The evidence against him is overwhelming. He took advantage of the learner at a school for learners with special needs. Mr. Ntshangase is guilty as charged. He violated his service contract, the legislative framework, and the SACE Code of Professional Ethics.
    Aggravating Factors
  2. It is expected of Mr. Ntshangase to act in loco parents and refrain from unjustifiable and forbidden relationships with learners. Mr. Ntshangase cannot be trusted to take care of learners.
  3. In Diholo v Gauteng Department of Education and Others (JR 1775/19) [2023] ZALCJHB 117 (2 May 2023), it was held that educators and management of our schools have a legal duty to care for the children entrusted to them. Learners are vulnerable. Teachers, as the closest adults during the learners’ school lives, have a positive duty to provide a safe educational environment, free from any form of fear, abuse, intimidation, coercion, or physical and/or emotional harm.
  4. The educator has to discharge extreme moral standards in the presence of learners and the community he serves. His actions must be beyond reproach as espoused in the SACE Code of Professional Ethics. The educator is expected to refrain from any form of sexual relationship with learners at any school. The educator must enable learners to develop values consistent with the fundamental rights contained in the Constitution of South Africa. Mr Ntshangase failed to uphold and acknowledge these values of the noble calling of being an educator.
  5. The Department of Education prohibits acts of sexual relationships between educators and learners, and a precedent should be set for Mr. Ntshangase and his colleagues, as this conduct violates the dignity of learners and puts the educational profession into disrepute.
  6. The employer prays that Mr. Ntshangase should be dismissed for contravention of Section 17(1)(b) and (c) and Section 18 (1) (q) of the Employment of Educators Act of 1996; his name should be recorded in the National Register of Sex Offenders, as he is not fit to work with children. ANALYSIS OF EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENTS
  7. Mr Ntshangase waived his right to state his case, challenge the Employer’s witnesses, and mitigate the sanction if found guilty, by refusing and failing to attend this inquiry. Therefore, my determination will be based on the unchallenged evidence presented before me. I agree with the Employer’s argument that his absence was calculated, as he lacked a defence to rebut the offences alleged against him.
  8. NM’s unchallenged testimony is that Mr Ntshangase proposed a sexual relationship with her, which she accepted. He hugged and kissed her in his classroom on numerous occasions. He enquired if she was a virgin and advised her to keep her virginity for him.
  9. He communicated with NM on WhatsApp and requested her to send him a nude video clip. Indeed, she complied and sent it to him. NM’s mother corroborated her version that she went through NM’s phone. She saw the WhatsApp exchanges between NM and Mr Ntshangase. She saw NM’s nude video clip that she sent to Mr Ntshangase. Furthermore, she saw the pornographic pictures that he sent NM.
  10. The mother confirmed that the nude video clip which was played in the proceedings was that of her daughters, and the pornographic pictures were retrieved from NM’s phone, exchanged with Mr Ntshangase. They both confirmed that NM’s phone was in the possession of the Investigating Officer (SAPS).
  11. The video clip and pornographic pictures are not in dispute. I find the NM and NZ’s testimony to be probable, notwithstanding the absence of the original phone that stored the messages. The explanation for not presenting NM’s phone is plausible. Her mother extracted the videos and pictures from her phone.
  12. In the absence of any contrary testimony, I am persuaded, on the balance of probability, that the WhatsApp messages were exchanged between Mr Ntshangase and NM. Therefore, he authored the messages.
  13. NZ’s unchallenged testimony is that NM confirmed to her the romantic relationship with Mr Ntshangase. This occurrence is consistent with what NZ informed the School Principal. The kissing and hugging in his classroom are unchallenged.
  14. These unchallenged, disgraceful messages and despicable conduct are from an educator to an 18-year-old Grade 5 learner with special needs. Therefore, the Employer has successfully proved on the balance of probabilities that Ntshangase has committed the three offences. I find Mr Ntshangase guilty as charged.

SANCTION
33. Mr Ntshangase ’s refusal to attend this inquiry demonstrates a lack of remorse for these appalling offences. He displays brazenness and shows no regard for the outcome of these proceedings. His attitude is: ‘do anything you want, I do not care’.

  1. In terms of Section 17 (1) (b) and (c) of the Employment of Educators Act of 1998, “Act”, an appropriate and mandatory sanction for a sexual assault of a learner and a sexual relationship with a learner is dismissal. Therefore, the count 1 and 3 offences that Mr Ntshangase committed carry a mandatory dismissal sanction. No amount of mitigation, even if any, could lessen the sanction.
  2. In relation to count 2: requesting nude pictures and sending NM pornographic pictures, the offence is serious, disgraceful, and distasteful. This affected both NM and NZ. NZ testified that she felt bad and disappointed about Mr Ntshangase pleasing himself with her daughter’s nude video clip. Mr Ntshangase took advantage of NM’s challenged situation.
  3. He committed the offence against a young adolescent girl with special needs. She looked upon him as a parent and an educator. NM and her parent entrusted him to care for her educational needs at school. As an educator for learners with special needs, he was entrusted with extra responsibility, care, and protection. He abused his power to feed his lust. The outcome not only destroyed the trust relationship but also injured the victim emotionally and psychologically.
  4. His actions are seriously harmful and destructive to the core. He destroyed the trust relationship with NM and other learners, his employer, and the community at large. He abused his position as an educator and loco parentis. I accept the Employer’s aggravating factors in this respect.
  5. He had disgracefully violated the victim’s constitutional right to dignity and education. He exposed the NM in a way that no mitigating factor would sound. He abused his position and relationship to prey on the innocent child.
  6. In Le Roux v S (A & R 25/2018) [2021] ZAECGHC 57 (13 May 2021), the court

held that “The interests of the community cannot be ignored in determining an
appropriate sentence. Some of the components of the offences occurred on the
premises of a primary school. It is also necessary to continue to impress upon
people in positions of responsibility that they cannot leverage their power, and
the esteem with which they may be regarded, to satisfy their sexual lust.

  1. I agree with the Employer that a strong message is necessary to deter potential transgressors from committing this horrendous act. The objective is to protect and safeguard the future and dignity of the learners. I find that dismissal is an appropriate sanction.
  2. I find Mr Sonke Lesley Ntshangase unsuitable to work with children. I invoke Section 120(2) of the Children’s Act No. 38 of 2005 to declare him unsuitable to
    work with children. Therefore, Mr Sonke Lesley Ntshangase must be entered in Part B of the National Child Protection Register, in terms of Section 122 of the Children’s Act.
  3. The General Secretary of the ELRC must, in terms of Section 122(1) of
    The Children’s Act No 38 of 2005, notify the Director-General: Department
    of Social Development in writing about the findings of this forum made in
    terms of Section 120 (4) of the Children’s Act No 38 of 2005, that Mr Sonke
    Lesley Ntshangase is unsuitable for working with children, for the Director-
    General to enter his name in Part B of the National Child Protection Register.
  4. The attention of SACE is drawn to the fact that Mr Sonke Lesley Ntshangase had sexually harassed and had engaged in a sexual relationship with a learner
    with special needs.
  5. The ELRC is directed to forward a copy of this award to SACE.

Signed and dated at Pretoria on 18 November 2026.

MG Rabyanyana
ELRC Panellist