IN THE MATTER BETWEEN:
SADTU obo K.B. Kunene Applicant
And
Department of Education KWAZULU-NATAL Respondent
ARBITRATION AWARD
Case Number: ELRC80-26/27KZN
Date of Award: 17 November 2026
ELRC Arbitrator: T Mtolo
DETAILS OF HEARING AND REPRESENTATION
- This inquiry by arbitrator in terms of section 188A of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 was held on 22 October 2026 at 4 Klebbe Street, Mkhuze. The applicant was represented by Mr S.M. Zulu of SADTU and the respondent by Ms N.S.Z. Nxumalo. The services of an interpreter and an intermediary were used. The process was digitally recorded.
- The applicant pleaded guilty to the charge and did not dispute the contents of the respondent’s bundle. Written submissions on sanction were filed by both parties by 29 October 2026 and have been considered.
BACKGROUND - The applicant is a permanent educator at Sinethezekile High School, Jozini, employed since 12 April 2012. He was charged in terms of items 5 and 7 of Schedule 2 to the Employment of Educators Act 76 of 1998 (the EEA) with improper conduct under section 18(1)(q), in that on or about 13 June 2025 he sent sexually explicit content to a WhatsApp group of Grade 11 class representatives, established for school matters.
- The applicant sent sexually explicit content to the learners in the group. It includes an image of a female body with exposed male genitalia; an image of women dancing in which one woman’s genitals were exposed; an image carrying the words “your hole is our goal”, with his own caption adding to the innuendo; a text reading that it will hurt, and hurt, and then one day it won’t; and a post about a 30 year old woman seen with a 17 year old boy, carrying its own innuendo. The learners reacted with laughter and comment.
- The bundle also contains an allegation that a parent warned the applicant to stop, and a statement by a learner that he sent her private messages.
ISSUE TO BE DECIDED - The appropriate sanction in terms of section 18(3) of the EEA, and whether the applicant is unsuitable to work with children in terms of section 120 of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005.
SURVEY OF EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENTS
Applicant’s submissions - The applicant relies on his plea and remorse, his service and clean record, his dependents, and his inpatient treatment in May 2026. He submits that dismissal would be disproportionate.
Respondent’s submissions - The respondent submits that the content was sexual and degrading of girls and breached the trust placed in the applicant by learners and parents. It accepts that he is remorseful and asks for suspension without pay for three months.
ANALYSIS - The applicant pleaded guilty to misconduct of a sexual nature under section 18(1)(q) of the EEA. Section 17(1) does not apply, but section 18(3)(i) permits dismissal where the nature or extent of the misconduct warrants it. The respondent’s proposal of suspension without pay does not bind me.
- The applicant sent the Grade 11 class representatives an image of a female body with exposed male genitalia, an image of dancing women in which one woman’s genitals were exposed, the “your hole is our goal” image, the text that it will hurt until one day it won’t, and a post about a 30 year old woman and a 17 year old boy carrying its own innuendo. Sent by an educator to children through a school group, this content is sexually explicit and wholly inappropriate. It desensitizes learners to sexual content and sexual language, and it has the hallmarks of sexual grooming. The SACE Code of Professional Ethics prohibits conduct of this kind towards learners.
- The applicant was not charged with the conduct alleged by the parent and the learner, and no finding is made on it.
- The Council has consistently dismissed educators for sexual communication with learners, including where they pleaded guilty and showed remorse: Head of Department: Gauteng Department of Education and Chabalala ELRC1067-25/26GP (guilty plea to sexual WhatsApp messages to a Grade 9 learner; dismissed and found unsuitable to work with children); Booyse and Western Cape Education Department ELRC18-22/23WC (admitted inappropriate WhatsApp messages to a Grade 9 learner; dismissal upheld).
- The applicant’s plea, remorse, fourteen years without a disciplinary record and his dependents are acknowledged. The clinical reports address distress caused by the disciplinary process, not the misconduct. None of this outweighs the gravity of sending sexually explicit content to learners, and a suspension would return him to a position of trust over children. Dismissal is the appropriate sanction.
- Section 120(1)(c) of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005 permits a forum in disciplinary proceedings concerning conduct relating to a child to find a person unsuitable to work with children, and section 120(2) permits it to do so of its own accord, as was done in Department of Education Eastern Cape and Balan ELRC289-25/26EC. Given the nature of the admitted conduct and the best interests of children under section 28(2) of the Constitution, the applicant is unsuitable to work with children.
AWARD - I make the following award:
15.1 The applicant, Mr Kwanele Bhekani Kunene, is found guilty, on his plea, of misconduct in terms of section 18(1)(q) of the EEA.
15.2 In terms of section 18(3)(i) of the EEA, the applicant is dismissed with effect from the date of this award.
15.3 The applicant, Mr Kwanele Bhekani Kunene, is found to be unsuitable to work with children in terms of section 120(2) of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005.
15.4 The General Secretary of the ELRC is, in terms of section 122(1) of the Children’s Act, ordered to immediately notify the Director-General of the Department of Social Development in writing of the findings of this forum made in terms of section 120 of the Children’s Act, that Mr Kwanele Bhekani Kunene is unsuitable to work with children, for the Director-General to enter his name as contemplated in section 120 in Part B of the Register.
15.5 The General Secretary of the ELRC must forward a copy of this award to the South African Council for Educators.
15.6 There is no order as to costs.
T. Mtolo
ELRC Arbitrator
17 November 2026

