IN THE EDUCATION LABOUR RELATIONS COUNCIL
Case No ELRC48-26/27FS
In the matter between:
N.J. Makhutla Applicant / Union
and
Department of Education Free State Respondent
PANELLIST: Nkosinati Cotho
HEARD: 28 October 2026
DELIVERED: 20 November 2026
Representation:
Union/Applicant’s representative: Este vd Merwe (Attorney from De Wet, Wepener Attorneys)
Respondent’s representative: V. Gubuza (Labour Relations Manager)
ARBITRATION AWARD
Proceedings and representation
- The dispute concerns the termination of the Applicant’s employment on 26 March 2026. The matter was heard on 28 August 2026 and on 28 October 2026 at Bahale Secondary School.
- At the hearing, legal representation was permitted following an ex-tempore ruling.
- The Applicant and Respondent presented their respective cases.
- The parties filed closing arguments, including the Respondent’s written submissions dated 2 November 2026.
Preliminary application for legal representation - At the commencement of the arbitration hearing on 28 August 2026, the Applicant applied for permission to be represented by a legal practitioner.
- The application was dealt with as a preliminary issue before the evidence on the merits was heard.
Applicant’s submissions on legal representation:
- The Applicant sought legal representation, relying on the legal nature and complexity of the dispute, including the interaction between the SACE registration requirements, the statutory basis for termination and the fairness provisions governing dismissal.
- The Applicant also relied on the parties’ comparative ability to present the case and the interests of justice.
Respondent’s submissions on legal representation:
9. The matter was not a complex matter that needed legal representation.
10. It was not a matter of public interest.
11. The comparative ability was not argued.
Ex-tempore ruling:
- Having considered the application and the applicable ELRC provisions governing legal representation, I granted the Applicant permission to be represented by a legal practitioner.
- The ruling was delivered orally at the hearing, and the arbitration proceeded thereafter.
- The considerations included the nature of the questions of law raised, the complexity of the dispute and the comparative ability of the parties to deal with those questions.
- The grant of legal representation was a preliminary procedural ruling.
- It did not determine the merits of the dismissal dispute or alter the statutory onus applicable to the parties.
Issues for determination
- The questions are whether the Respondent proved a fair reason for dismissal; whether a fair procedure was followed; and, if unfairness is established, the appropriate remedy.
- Central to the enquiry is the distinction between registration with SACE and production of a SACE certificate, together with the actual statutory and factual reason advanced for termination.
Background and chronology
- The Applicant commenced employment as a temporary educator in 2009 and stated that he became permanently appointed in January 2012.
- He testified that he had been studying Project Management at the Central University of Technology (CUT) before being asked to assist with Accounting and Business Economics teaching at Bahale S.S. School.
- The precise teaching qualification was not established in the evidence summarized, but the Respondent did not put his eligibility to teach in dispute; this is not adopted as an alternative ground of dismissal.
- The SACE certificate records 13 February 2026 as the date of first registration.
- Correspondence from the Department is dated 25 February 2026; the Applicant responded in March 2026.
- His services were terminated on 26 March 2026, and the SACE certificate was issued on 27 March 2026.
- The legal effect of the recorded registration date must be assessed on the admitted and proven evidence.
Summary of the Respondent’s case
Ms. M. V. Nhlapo (Principal) testified under oath:
26. The Respondent contended that the Applicant had been informed since December 2025 of a registration problem, failed to regularize or demonstrate compliance timeously, and did not produce the SACE certificate before 26 March 2026.
27. It relied on section 21(2) of the South African Council for Educators Act 31 of 2000, maintaining that it could not employ an educator without proof of registration and that dismissal was fair.
28. Its closing arguments acknowledged that the subsequently issued certificate records first registration on 13 February 2026.
29. The Principal named educators who offered assistance to the Applicant, but those educators were not called to corroborate the offers.
30. Under cross-examination, she was unable to supply reliable dates and details for certain disputed verbal interactions.
31. The documented notices must be assessed separately from these disputed allegations.
32. Alleged shortcomings concerning Grade 12 reports and qualifications should not be treated as independent reasons for dismissal unless shown to have formed part of the employer’s actual reasons and fairly ventilated at arbitration.
Summary of the Applicant’s case
- The Applicant disputed substantive and procedural fairness.
- He relied on long service, deductions described as SACE-related, his belief that registration was in order, correspondence with the Department, the registration date of 13 February 2026, recorded in the certificate, and an alleged absence of meaningful consultation or consideration of his representations.
- He challenged the employer’s reliance on statutory non-compliance after many years of employment and seeks reinstatement.
- His arguments about employer’s fault and estoppel must be evaluated under the governing statute; past non-compliance does not, by itself, legalize a prohibited appointment.
Analysis of arguments and evidence
- Section 23(1) of the Constitution protects fair labour practices.
- The applicable ELRC Constitution and dispute-resolution procedures govern the conduct of the arbitration; the statutory unfair-dismissal framework remains relevant to the substantive rights and permissible remedies.
- Section 21 of the South African Council for Educators Act 31 of 2000 requires registration and prohibits employment of an unregistered educator.
- Sections 11 and 16 of the Employment of Educators Act 76 of 1998 and its relevant schedules require careful examination in light of the ground actually relied upon.
- The ELRC Constitution is the primary procedural instrument referred to in this award.
- The principles in Sidumo and Another v Rustenburg Platinum Mines Ltd and Others 2008 (2) SA 24 (CC), concerning an independent fairness assessment, and Stellenbosch Farmers’ Winery Group Ltd and Another v Martell et Cie and Others 2003 (1) SA 11 (SCA), concerning credibility, reliability and probabilities, may be relevant.
- The Respondent bears the onus of proving fairness as dismissal was common cause.
- Its reliance on the absence of a SACE certificate must be distinguished from proof that the Applicant was not registered on the termination date.
- The SACE certificate’s stated first-registration date predates dismissal.
- According to the evidence as clarified at arbitration, the Applicant’s eligibility to teach at the termination date was not disputed. The lack of documentary proof furnished to the employer must not be equated with an absence of registration.
- The employer’s knowledge at the time and the fairness of its decision must also be considered.
- The Principal’s evidence of documented warnings may carry weight.
- The Principal’s account of further oral assistance is not automatically inadmissible because the named educators did not testify. Still, the absence of direct corroboration, uncertain dates, and the Applicant’s dispute may reduce its weight.
- An adverse inference from absent witnesses is not automatic.
- The Applicant’s own diligence and response to documented notices remain relevant.
- Neither earlier delay nor the employer’s historic failure to check registration conclusively determines the fairness of termination.
- The Respondent has variously characterized the issue as incapacity or statutory non-compliance.
- A lack of legal eligibility is not necessarily equivalent to poor work performance.
- The employer must identify and establish the reason for which it acted, and the applicable process must be evaluated accordingly.
- Evidence about academic qualifications or Grade 12 reports must not be used to substitute a new reason not relied upon at dismissal.
- It is common cause that the Respondent terminated the Applicant’s employment on 26 March 2026. The Respondent accordingly bears the burden of establishing the fairness of the dismissal.
- The certificate records the Applicant’s first SACE registration as 13 February 2026, before termination. The arbitration did not dispute his eligibility to teach on the dismissal date, given the evidence presently provided.
- The Respondent’s concern that it had not received the certificate before 26 March 2026 is distinguishable from an assertion that the Applicant was, in fact, unregistered on that date.
- The Applicant was not without responsibility. The documented requests required his attention, and he did not provide the Department with adequate documentary confirmation of registration before the dismissal decision. This omission materially contributed to the circumstances in which the decision was made.
- The Principal identified educators by name who allegedly offered assistance, but those persons did not testify. She was unable to provide reliable dates and details for some of the disputed interactions. I give limited weight to those additional oral allegations while separately assessing the documented notices.
- The Respondent did not call the officials responsible for assessing the Applicant’s written representations or deciding upon termination. Their absence is not automatically decisive, but limits the direct evidence explaining what was considered and why dismissal was regarded as necessary.
- The evidence concerning Grade 12 reports and the Applicant’s earlier studies at CUT does not establish a separate ground of dismissal. It would be unfair to replace the Department’s stated registration-related reason with an uncharged performance or qualification case.
- Having assessed the evidence, I find that the Respondent has not proved a substantively fair reason for termination. The SACE certificate records registration before dismissal; the Department’s failure to receive documentary confirmation is relevant, but does not of itself establish that the Applicant was unregistered or legally ineligible when dismissed.
- The Applicant made written representations in March 2026. The mere receipt of representations does not establish that they were meaningfully considered. On the evidence presently identified, the Respondent has not sufficiently demonstrated how the relevant representations were evaluated before termination.
- On the evidence identified, the Respondent has not established that the Applicant’s written representations were meaningfully considered before the termination decision. I find that procedural fairness has not been proved.
Remedy — six months’ limited retrospective reinstatement
- The Applicant seeks reinstatement. His long service and the absence of a disputed legal impediment to his continued teaching favour restoration of the employment relationship.
- Full financial retrospectivity is not appropriate on the facts found. Although dismissal was unfair, the Applicant failed to provide the employer with timely proof of registration despite documented requests. This conduct is relevant to the equitable extent of retrospective relief, but does not validate the dismissal.
- I determine that the reinstatement remedy should carry six months of retrospective remuneration, rather than full backpay from the dismissal date.
- At the monthly remuneration of R32,210.3638 recorded in the available evidence, six months back pay amount to R193,262.28 (one hundred and ninety-three thousand two hundred and sixty-two rand and twenty-eight cents).
Award
- The dismissal of the Applicant, N.J. Makhutla, by the Free State Department of Education on 26 March 2026 is found to be substantively and procedurally unfair.
- The Respondent is ordered to reinstate the Applicant to his former position, or a reasonably equivalent position on terms no less favourable. He must report for duty on 1 December 2026.
- The Respondent shall pay the Applicant retrospective remuneration of back pay in the amount of R193,262.28 (R32,210.38 × 6), by 5 December 2026.
DATED AT WELKOM ON THIS 20TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026.
Nkosinati Cotho
ELRC Panellist

