IN THE ELRC ARBITRATION
BETWEEN:
Tholakele Kunene APPLICANT
AND
The Department of Education: Gauteng Province RESPONDENT
ARBITRATION AWARD
CASE NUMBER: ELRC598-26/27GP
ARBITRATION DATE: 26 October 2026
DATE OF THE AWARD: 20 November 2026
ELRC Arbitrator: Pitsi Maitsha
Education Labour Relations Council
ELRC Building
261 West Avenue
Centurion
Tel: 012 663 0452
Fax: 012 643 1601
Website: www.elrc.org.za
DETAILS OF THE HEARING AND REPRESENTATION
- On 26 October 2026, an arbitration hearing was held virtually via Microsoft Teams under the auspices of the Education Labour Relations Council (ELRC), in terms of section 191(5)(a)(iv) of the Labour Relations Act, 66 of 1995, as amended (the LRA). This arbitration award is issued in terms of section 138(7) of the LRA.
- The applicant is Ms Tholakele Kunene, who was in attendance and represented by Ms Yolanda Kubheka, a legal representative from Kabai Attorneys. The respondent is the Department of Education: Gauteng Province, which was represented by Mr Diketso Jafta, a Senior Education Specialist: Labour Relations.
- The parties gave their respective evidence under oath. The proceedings were conducted via Microsoft Teams and digitally recorded.
ISSUE TO BE DECIDED
4. I am required to determine whether the dismissal of the applicant was substantively and procedurally fair. Should I find that the dismissal was unfair, I am required to determine the appropriate remedy.
BACKGROUND DETAILS
5. The parties held a pre-arbitration meeting on 9 October 2026 and signed the pre-arbitration minutes on 12 October 2026. For purposes of this arbitration award, I will record the relevant agreements and issues arising from the pre-arbitration minutes as follows:
POSSIBILITY OF SETTLEMENT
6. The parties indicated that they had explored the possibility of settling the dispute but were unable to reach a settlement agreement. They accordingly agreed that the matter should proceed to arbitration.
COMMON CAUSE FACTS
7. The following facts were recorded as common cause:
7.1. The applicant commenced employment with the respondent on 1 February 2004.
7.2. The applicant was dismissed on 2 June 2026 following a disciplinary hearing.
ISSUES IN DISPUTE
8. The parties recorded the following issues as being in dispute:
8.1. Whether the applicant committed the alleged misconduct in the course and scope of her employment or in her personal capacity.
8.2. Whether the respondent followed a fair procedure, particularly whether the audi alteram partem principle was adhered to.
8.3. Whether the evidence presented against the applicant was obtained lawfully.
ISSUES TO BE DETERMINED BY THE COMMISSIONER
9. The Commissioner is required to determine:
9.1. Whether the dismissal of the applicant was substantively and procedurally fair.
9.2. Should the dismissal be found to be unfair, whether reinstatement would constitute an appropriate remedy.
RELIEF SOUGHT
10. The applicant seeks retrospective reinstatement.
11. Aggrieved by the respondent’s decision to dismiss her, the applicant referred an unfair dismissal dispute to the ELRC for arbitration. She seeks an order for retrospective reinstatement.
THE RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS
THE EVIDENCE OF MS PHINDILE KHUMALO
12. Ms Phindile Khumalo testified that she is currently employed as an educator at Emdeni Secondary School. She indicated that she had no personal relationship with the applicant.
13. She testified that she had no communication with the applicant until 2 February 2024, when she received a telephone call from a person who introduced herself as the Principal of Emdeni Secondary School. Later that day, she received another telephone call from a person who informed her that interview questions would be sent to her in advance of the interview. The caller further indicated that candidates from KwaZulu-Natal (KZN) were expected to pay R20 000,00 and that they wanted the post to be allocated to someone from Gauteng. Consequently, they would be lenient regarding the amount she was expected to pay.
14. She testified that she enquired about the amount being requested. The person indicated that the amount was R8 000,00. She responded that she could afford to pay R6 000,00, and the parties allegedly agreed on that amount. She explained that she was unemployed at the time and that it was for this reason that she offered R6 000,00. She was further informed that she could pay the full amount after the interview.
15. She testified that on 3 February 2024, she contacted the principal to request directions to the interview venue, as she was unfamiliar with the area. The Principal subsequently sent her the location via WhatsApp. She also enquired whether the interview questions could be provided to her in advance. However, the Principal informed her that she should attend the interview and that the questions would not be disclosed beforehand. It was at that stage that she realised that she had been communicating with two different individuals.
16. She further testified that she subsequently received the interview questions via WhatsApp from the applicant.
17. She testified that she did not know how the applicant had obtained her cellphone number, just as she did not know how the principal had obtained it. She indicated that the individuals who initially contacted her had not introduced themselves but had promised to send her the interview questions before the interview. The following day, however, one of the individuals identified herself as Ms Kunene. She reiterated that she had been informed that she could pay the agreed amount of R6 000,00 after the interview.
18. She testified that her understanding of the arrangement was that payment of the amount would secure her appointment to the advertised post, particularly because she had graduated approximately seven years earlier and had been unemployed. She informed her mother about the arrangement upon arriving home. However, she did not report the matter to anyone at that stage.
19. She testified that the cellphone number appearing on the interview questions and suggested answers belonged to the applicant, as she had received the questions from that same number. According to her, the applicant had instructed her not to disclose the arrangement to anyone. She further indicated that only two of the questions asked during the interview had not appeared in the material sent to her beforehand. She maintained that the applicant had provided her with the cellphone number from which the questions were sent.
20. She testified that the individuals she could show at the interview were the applicant and the principal.
21. She further testified that she subsequently received a telephone call from the Principal enquiring whether she was still in the area so that she could come and sign the relevant appointment forms. The Principal, however, indicated that she could attend on Monday, as she was in Spruit View at the time. Approximately two hours later, she received a telephone call from the applicant enquiring whether she had received a call from the principal. She confirmed that she had. The applicant then reminded her that she should honour their agreement. Consequently, she sent the applicant R3 000,00 through a cash-send facility. She explained that she only paid half of the agreed amount because she was still sceptical about the arrangement. The applicant had specifically instructed her to use the cash-send facility.
22. She testified that she paid the outstanding balance on 6 February 2024 by sending the applicant the cash-send collection number and PIN. In response, the applicant sent her a voice note thanking her for the payment.
23. She further testified that there was no communication between herself and the applicant after the payment of the outstanding balance until 22 March 2024, when the applicant contacted her requesting money on behalf of another person who had allegedly signed the relevant forms. The amount requested was R4 000,00. She indicated that the applicant had activated the disappearing messages function on her cellphone. According to her, the money was intended for the SGB Chairperson. She responded that she did not have the money because she was still paying off a loan she had incurred when relocating from KZN.
24. She testified that the applicant subsequently confirmed receipt of the money previously sent. The applicant also indicated that if she needed the garage, it was still available. The applicant further suggested that, if she could not afford R4 000,00, she could pay either R3 500,00 or R2 500,00. She eventually paid R2 000,00, explaining that she had not known about the involvement of a third person when the initial arrangement was made.
25. She further testified that she recognised the applicant’s voice in the voice notes and that the cellphone numbers used to communicate with her belonged to the applicant. She explained that she was able to identify the applicant through her WhatsApp status and profile picture.
26. She testified that she eventually decided to report the matter in November 2024 after the applicant contacted her in October 2024 demanding R20 000,00 on the basis that she would be made a permanent employee, as she was still employed on a temporary basis at the time.
27. She further testified that she received a telephone call from the SGB Chairperson, who informed her that she had heard that the applicant was soliciting money in her name. She denied that this was true and said that the situation made her uncomfortable. She consequently decided that the matter had escalated beyond what she could tolerate and reported it to the principal in early November 2024.
28. She also testified that she had heard from a family member, Ms Ndlovu, that the applicant required money to facilitate the permanent appointment of her post. She did not enquire from the SGB Chairperson about the source of the information. She indicated that the applicant continued requesting money from her and that the matter needed to be addressed through the appropriate channels. She reported the matter to the principal, who advised her to approach the District Office.
29. Under cross-examination, Ms Khumalo conceded that she did not have recordings of the telephone conversations to substantiate the sequence of events she had described. She acknowledged that, in the absence of such recordings, certain aspects of her testimony could be regarded as hearsay. However, she maintained that the screenshots presented were authentic.
30. She testified that she could establish that she had received a call from the applicant because she subsequently received the interview questions after communicating with her. She further maintained that the cellphone numbers belonged to the applicant, referring to the applicant’s email address and the cellphone number commencing with 081. Regarding the number commencing with 069, she conceded that she had no independent evidence establishing that it belonged to the applicant. However, she maintained that she had called the applicant and that the applicant had provided her with the interview questions.
31. She testified that she eventually reported the matter because the applicant continued soliciting money from her. She maintained that she had applied for the advertised position through the normal recruitment process and that it was the applicant who had approached her and offered to provide her with the interview questions.
32. She further testified that she had been unemployed for approximately seven years and was desperate to secure employment. She acknowledged that she was aware that people sometimes paid money to secure employment opportunities. At the time, however, she did not see the need to report the arrangement and questioned whom she could have approached to report it. She maintained that she was certain that the applicant was not acting in collaboration with the principal.
THE EVIDENCE OF MR TEBOGO MASHIGO: PRINCIPAL OF EMDENI SECONDARY SCHOOL
33. Mr Tebogo Mashigo testified that he was the Principal of Emdeni Secondary School from 2018 until 2025, when he was deployed to another school. He knew the applicant, who had been employed as an educator at Emdeni Secondary School before being deployed to Zibambele Primary School following an allegation of sexual harassment against him. He further testified that he became acquainted with Ms Khumalo during the recruitment process in February 2024, and that she was subsequently employed as an educator at Emdeni Secondary School.
34. He testified that the allegations levelled against the applicant were formulated as follows: Allegation 1: It is alleged that on or around 4 February 2024, while serving as a panel member for a Post Level 1 position at Emdeni Secondary School, the applicant committed an act of dishonesty in that she received an amount of R3 000,00 as a bribe from Ms P. Khumalo. Allegation 2: It is alleged that on or around 6 February 2024, while serving as a panel member for a Post Level 1 position at Emdeni Secondary School, the applicant committed an act of dishonesty in that she received an amount of R3 000,00 as a bribe from Ms P. Khumalo. Allegation 3: It is alleged that on or around 23 March 2024, while serving as a panel member for a Post Level 1 position at Emdeni Secondary School, the applicant committed an act of dishonesty in that she demanded and received an amount of R2 000,00 from Ms P. Khumalo in exchange for the renewal of her contract. Allegation 4: It is alleged that on or around 3 February 2024, the applicant committed an act of dishonesty in that she sent interview questions for a Post Level 1 position at Emdeni Secondary School to Ms P. Khumalo.
35. He testified that, during November 2024, Ms Khumalo reported to him that an individual had been continuously soliciting money from her. She identified the applicant, whom she referred to as Madam Kunene, as the person allegedly demanding the money. He confirmed that the applicant was an SGB member and had served on the interview panel.
36. He explained that, at the initial stages of the recruitment process, the entire SGB structure nominated a panel, which was responsible for conducting the shortlisting and interviewing processes. The panel would also prepare a management plan to guide the recruitment process.
37. He testified that the panel members he could recall included himself and the applicant, although he was uncertain whether Nomvula was also a member. He explained that the panel convened on a Saturday to conduct the shortlisting process and thereafter contacted the shortlisted candidates. On Sunday morning, at approximately 08h00, before the interviews commenced, the panel discussed and formulated the interview questions. The questions were prepared on the same day as the interviews.
38. He further testified that, ordinarily, the panel secretary was responsible for inviting candidates to attend interviews or contacting them telephonically. However, during the meeting, the panel agreed that he, as the Principal, would contact the candidates. He accordingly contacted the three shortlisted candidates. He could recall Ms Khumalo, a candidate from KZN and another candidate from Gauteng. Ultimately, only one candidate attended the interview, as the other two candidates failed to arrive. One of the candidates from KZN sent an SMS apologising for her inability to attend.
39. He testified that, on the morning of the interviews, the panel discussed the questions and individual members were afforded an opportunity to propose questions for inclusion. Several questions were proposed by the parent component of the panel. He also participated in the process and proposed two questions. He described the applicant’s participation as particularly active, indicating that she contributed significantly towards structuring the interview questions.
40. He further testified that the panel tasked him with contacting the successful candidate to inform her that she had been selected and that she was required to attend to complete the relevant forms, as the school urgently needed an educator to teach the learners. Ms Khumalo subsequently attended on Monday to complete the necessary documentation.
41. He testified that Ms Khumalo was distressed by the continuous demands for money allegedly made by the applicant and eventually reported the matter to him. She showed him some evidence of cash-send transactions. He explained that, as Principal, his responsibility was not to investigate the allegations but to refer the matter to the appropriate authorities.
42. He accordingly instructed Ms Khumalo to prepare a written report and submit it to the Labour Relations Office and the District Office. He explained that he did not personally investigate the allegations because they were serious and concerned the Department of Education. He further indicated that there was an ongoing public outcry regarding the alleged selling of posts in public schools and that, had he attempted to deal with the matter without escalating it, he could have been accused by the Department of concealing relevant information.
43. Under cross-examination, he testified that he only escalated the matter after examining the evidence presented to him by Ms Khumalo. He recalled asking a question during the interview which Ms Khumalo did not answer. However, he indicated that she answered the other questions exceptionally well. He suggested that this could have been because some of the questions had been provided to her in advance by members of the panel, including the applicant and members representing the parent component.
44. He further testified that Ms Khumalo did not know beforehand which questions he intended to ask during the interview.
45. He maintained that the applicant was employed by the respondent and had also served as an SGB member. He argued that misconduct of this nature, even if committed in the applicant’s capacity as an SGB member, could potentially bring the respondent into disrepute and undermine the integrity of the teaching profession.
46. He further testified that the Public Ordinary Schools Office (POS) dealt with the matter and that it was resolved that the applicant should be removed from the SGB. He indicated that the respondent considered it appropriate to institute disciplinary proceedings against the applicant in relation to her professional ethics as an educator. He maintained that the matter was beyond his authority and understanding to deal with independently.
THE EVIDENCE OF MR WINSTON RAYMOND TSHABALALA: PRINCIPAL OF ZIBAMBELE PRIMARY SCHOOL
47. Mr Winston Raymond Tshabalala testified that he was the Principal of Zibambele Primary School, a position he had held since 2009. He described his period of service as approximately eighteen years.
48. He testified that he knew the applicant as one of the educators employed at his school following her transfer from Emdeni Secondary School.
49. He testified that, on 14 May 2026, Mr Jafta visited Zibambele Primary School and indicated that he wished to see the applicant. He went to the applicant’s classroom, called her and informed her that an official from the Department of Education wished to see her. Upon her arrival, he left the applicant with Mr Jafta in his office.
50. He later observed the applicant returning to her classroom and went back to his office. Mr Jafta subsequently informed him that he had intended to serve the applicant with certain documents but that she had refused to sign them.
51. He testified that he again called the applicant and advised her to accept the documents, read through them and sign where necessary. However, the applicant again refused, indicating that Mr Jafta should consult her union because she was a union member. He subsequently signed the relevant document to confirm that the applicant had refused to sign the documents.
52. Under cross-examination, he conceded that he was unaware of the nature and contents of the documents in question. He explained that he had not read them because they were intended for the applicant and not for him.
THE RESPONDENT’S CLOSING ARGUMENTS
53. Mr Jafta, on behalf of the respondent, submitted that the applicant had been charged with four allegations of misconduct relating to dishonesty, bribery and the disclosure of interview questions for a Post Level 1 position at Emdeni Secondary School.
54. He submitted that the allegations arose from the applicant’s alleged receipt of R3 000,00 from Ms Khumalo on or around 4 February 2024, a further R3 000,00 on or around 6 February 2024, and R2 000,00 on or around 23 March 2024, allegedly in exchange for securing her appointment and subsequent contract renewal. The fourth allegation related to the applicant’s alleged disclosure of interview questions to Ms Khumalo on or around 3 February 2024.
55. He indicated that the applicant had been charged in terms of section 18(1)(e) of the Employment of Educators Act 76 of 1998, as amended.
56. Mr Jafta submitted that the respondent had presented reliable evidence which was corroborated by the testimony of its witnesses. He argued that the applicant’s participation in the recruitment and selection process, considered together with Ms Khumalo’s testimony that she had received the interview questions beforehand, was significant. He submitted that this version was corroborated by Mr Mashigo, who confirmed that the applicant had actively participated in formulating the interview questions.
57. He further submitted that the applicant had conceded that she communicated with Ms Khumalo outside the formal interview process without disclosing such communication to the other panel members. He also argued that the applicant had acknowledged that the cash-deposit or cash-send receipts had been sent to her but had failed to question why they had been sent to her. He further relied on the cellphone number appearing in the screenshots, which he submitted belonged to the applicant.
58. Mr Jafta further argued that the applicant had not denied that the voice note originated from her. He submitted that the applicant had generally failed to rebut the respondent’s evidence and had instead maintained a blanket denial of the allegations throughout the proceedings.
59. He submitted that the applicant’s explanation should be assessed against Ms Khumalo’s direct testimony and the electronic evidence presented by the respondent. In support of this submission, he referred to Platinum Mile Resources (Pty) Ltd v CCMA and Others (2023) ZALC JHB 52, in which the Labour Court considered the evidentiary consequences of a party’s failure to put a contradictory version to a witness during cross-examination, thereby affording that witness an opportunity to respond.
60. He argued that where the applicant’s version materially contradicted credible evidence that had not been challenged during cross-examination, and was inconsistent with the probabilities, such version should be rejected.
61. Regarding procedural fairness, Mr Jafta submitted that the applicant had conceded under cross-examination that the matter had previously been postponed because her union representative was unavailable. He further indicated that the applicant had requested further postponements on 5 and 6 February 2026 on the basis that she was booked off sick, notwithstanding that she had allegedly been at work on those dates.
62. In support of the respondent’s position, he referred to the Supreme Court of Appeal decision in Old Mutual Life Assurance Co SA Ltd v Gumbi (2007), submitting that an employee who has been afforded an opportunity to be heard but fails to utilise that opportunity cannot automatically rely on the resulting absence to establish procedural unfairness.
63. He argued that the applicant’s history of postponement requests and her alleged attendance at work on the scheduled dates were relevant considerations in determining whether her absence was justified. He submitted that the applicant had been afforded a reasonable opportunity to participate in the proceedings but had failed to do so without adequate justification. Accordingly, her absence did not necessarily render the disciplinary proceedings procedurally unfair.
64. Mr Jafta further submitted that the applicant’s contention that she had acted in her capacity as an SGB member, rather than as an educator, did not absolve her of accountability.
65. In this regard, he referred to Maloka v CCMA and Others (2016) ZALC JHB 343 and Hoechst (Pty) Ltd v Chemical Workers Industrial Union and Another (1993) 14 ILJ 1449 (LAC), which, according to his submission, recognise that misconduct committed outside the workplace or in an employee’s private capacity may justify disciplinary action where there is a sufficient connection between the misconduct and the employer’s interests.
66. He argued that the alleged acceptance of bribes during a recruitment process involving the Department of Education directly compromised the integrity of the recruitment process and raised serious concerns regarding the trust relationship between the applicant and the respondent.
67. He submitted that the respondent had a legitimate interest in addressing the alleged misconduct, irrespective of the capacity in which the applicant claimed to have acted. He accordingly requested that I consider the totality of the evidence and, should I be satisfied that the allegations had been established on a balance of probabilities, find that the dismissal was fair and dismiss the applicant’s unfair dismissal claim.
THE APPLICANT’S SUBMISSIONS
THE SUBMISSIONS OF THE APPLICANT, MS THOLAKELE KUNENE
68. The applicant testified that she referred the dispute to the ELRC because she had submitted a medical certificate to the respondent and believed that she should have been afforded an opportunity to present her case. She maintained that the disciplinary proceedings continued in her absence because Mr Jafta was unwilling to accommodate a further postponement.
69. She testified that she first became acquainted with Ms Khumalo on the day of the interviews. She explained that she was serving as the chairperson in her capacity as a parent representative on the SGB. The other individuals present during the interviews included Oupa Gumede, Nomvula Ngwenya, Sibongile Shedzi, the Head of Department responsible for Home Languages, and the Principal, Mr Tebogo Mashigo.
70. She testified that she was the only person responsible for calling the candidates. She explained that each panel member had prepared questions for the interviews. After interviewing Ms Khumalo, she went to call the remaining candidates. However, no other candidates were present.
71. She further testified that, while she was attending to the other candidates, Ms Khumalo approached her and enquired whether she could assist her in securing the position. Ms Khumalo explained that she resided in Vosloorus, which was far from the school, and that she would require accommodation.
72. The applicant testified that she consequently requested Ms Khumalo’s cellphone number so that she could communicate with her should she identify suitable accommodation. She explained that Ms Khumalo was not the first person whom she had intended to assist with accommodation. She further testified that she explained the security arrangements and the amounts ordinarily required upfront to secure accommodation. Ms Khumalo subsequently went to inspect a cottage at a neighbouring school but was dissatisfied with the accommodation.
73. She testified that the SGB had agreed to appoint Ms Khumalo because the school required an educator to occupy a temporary post and teach Creative Arts. She explained that the Department had made it clear that educators would be deployed from other schools to address staffing shortages and fill vacant teaching positions.
74. The applicant denied extorting money from Ms Khumalo. She maintained that her intention was to assist Ms Khumalo in becoming a member of NATU and that the forms referred to in the evidence related to that process.
75. Under cross-examination, the applicant testified that she did not attend the disciplinary hearing because she was unaware of the invitation, as the notice had been sent to her union. She further explained that she did not attend because Mr Ndlovu, her union representative, was unavailable. She confirmed that Mr Ndlovu’s unavailability was the reason for her non-attendance.
76. She testified that she had no knowledge of the telephone calls referred to in the respondent’s evidence because she understood that all communication relating to the disciplinary proceedings would be directed to her through the union, which would attend to the necessary arrangements. She maintained that she was the person facing the disciplinary charges and that the respondent was therefore required to afford her an opportunity to present her case.
77. She testified that her disciplinary hearing took place on 20 February 2026. She further indicated that she had been booked off sick from 19 January 2026 until 17 February 2026. She explained that the appeal against the disciplinary proceedings had been prepared by her union and referred to an injury to her finger as the reason for requesting a postponement.
78. She conceded that the disciplinary hearing had not proceeded between September 2025 and March 2026, largely because of postponement requests made on her behalf.
79. Regarding the events of 14 May 2026, she testified that Mr Jafta had visited the school intending to serve her with documents for signature. She confirmed that she had been called to the office on that date. She explained that the Department official communicated with her about the hearing, but she had to return urgently to attend to her learners because she was concerned that she could be held responsible by the Department should anything happen to them.
80. The applicant conceded that there was no reason for her to communicate privately with Ms Khumalo outside the formal interview panel process. She further acknowledged that she had not informed the other panel members that Ms Khumalo had communicated with her privately. She also conceded that she had not disclosed the financial transaction to the other panel members.
81. She acknowledged that she had a professional relationship with Ms Khumalo but conceded that assisting her with accommodation was not part of her professional responsibilities.
82. She testified that the cellphone number commencing with 081 belonged to her. However, she denied receiving money from Ms Khumalo and maintained that she had only received the proof of payment or transaction receipts. She suggested that Ms Khumalo should explain to whom she had actually sent the money.
83. She further testified that Ms Khumalo had requested the Principal’s cellphone number before the interviews, which raised her suspicion that the Principal intended to engage in some improper conduct. She maintained that she had reported the matter in October 2024 after receiving a telephone call from Ms Khumalo’s father, Mr Ndlovu, who enquired about the advertised position. She indicated that she reported the matter to her SGB Chairperson.
84. During her testimony, she clarified that Ms Khumalo had requested the principal’s cellphone number after the interview.
85. She further acknowledged that the cellphone number commencing with 069 also belonged to her. She confirmed that she had sent Ms Khumalo a message stating: “Hi Ntombi, I hope things went well this time. Don’t forget to send”. She explained that the message referred to confirmation regarding the accommodation or garage.
86. She testified that she received the transaction receipt from Ms Khumalo but did not acknowledge receipt of the money.
87. The applicant further testified that she was familiar with the amounts ordinarily charged as security deposits for accommodation in her community. She explained that such deposits varied, with amounts ranging from R2 500,00 to R8 000,00, and that R3 000,00 was one of the amounts charged. She maintained that she had assisted Ms Khumalo with accommodation and that Ms Khumalo was required to choose which accommodation she preferred. She further indicated that she had even offered to rent out her own house to Ms Khumalo.
THE APPLICANT’S CLOSING ARGUMENTS
88. Ms Kubheka, on behalf of the applicant, submitted that the respondent had failed to discharge its onus of proving, on a balance of probabilities, that the applicant’s dismissal was substantively and procedurally fair.
89. Regarding procedural fairness, she argued that the disciplinary proceedings had been conducted in the applicant’s absence and that the respondent had failed to comply with the audi alteram partem principle. She maintained that the applicant had submitted a medical certificate and should have been afforded a reasonable opportunity to present her case before a decision to dismiss her was taken.
90. As a preliminary point, Ms Kubheka challenged the respondent’s authority to discipline the applicant for conduct allegedly committed in her capacity as an SGB member rather than as an educator.
91. She submitted that the alleged interaction between the applicant and Ms Khumalo occurred in the context of the applicant’s participation in school governance as an SGB member and parent representative, and not in the performance of her duties as an educator. She argued that the Department of Education had exceeded its statutory powers by instituting disciplinary proceedings against the applicant for conduct which fell outside its disciplinary jurisdiction.
92. She further submitted that the respondent ought to have referred the matter to the SGB for consideration under its internal governance processes, as the SGB is an independent statutory structure established in terms of the South African Schools Act.
93. Ms Kubheka argued that the respondent had failed to identify the specific provision of the Employment of Educators Act 76 of 1998 that empowered it to discipline the applicant for actions allegedly performed in her capacity as an SGB member under the South African Schools Act.
94. In support of this submission, she referred to the Constitutional Court judgment in Federation of Governing Bodies of South African Schools v Member of the Executive Council for Education, Gauteng (FEDSAS), arguing that the judgment recognises the statutory governance authority of SGBs and the limits on the extent to which departmental officials may interfere with their governance functions.
95. She accordingly submitted that the respondent’s conduct was ultra vires. She argued that the respondent had interfered with the applicant’s personal life and her capacity as a parent and SGB member, thereby infringing upon her constitutional and statutory rights to participate in the governance of the school attended by her child.
96. Regarding substantive fairness, Ms Kubheka submitted that the onus rested on the respondent to establish that the alleged misconduct had been committed and that dismissal was an appropriate sanction. She argued that the respondent had failed to discharge this onus on a balance of probabilities.
97. She further submitted that the respondent’s documentary bundle did not contain an investigation report or a certificate demonstrating compliance with the Regulation of Interception of Communications and Provision of Communication-Related Information Act 70 of 2002 (RICA). She argued that the respondent had failed to demonstrate that the evidence had been properly obtained and that the credibility of the allegations had been adequately investigated before disciplinary proceedings were instituted.
98. She contended that the evidence relied upon by the respondent should be excluded on the basis that it had allegedly been obtained in an unconstitutional or unlawful manner.
99. Ms Kubheka further challenged the reliability of Ms Khumalo’s testimony. She submitted that Ms Khumalo had conceded under cross-examination that she had been unemployed since 2018 and was desperate to secure employment. She argued that Ms Khumalo’s circumstances should be considered when assessing the reliability and credibility of her allegations.
100. She further argued that Ms Khumalo’s evidence regarding the alleged telephone conversations was hearsay, as she had failed to produce recordings or independent evidence establishing that the applicant had made the alleged calls. She submitted that Ms Khumalo had failed to establish that the interview questions were in fact sent to her by the applicant.
101. Ms Kubheka further questioned why Ms Khumalo had sent screenshots of the cash-send transactions to the applicant if, as she alleged, the applicant had not received the money or provided her with the interview questions. She submitted that the circumstances surrounding the transactions were insufficiently explained and that the respondent had failed to establish the necessary link between the applicant and the alleged payments.
102. In support of her argument regarding hearsay evidence, she referred to the Labour Court judgment in NTU Company (Pty) Ltd v CEPPWAWU obo Ngwenya, submitting that the Court had emphasised the evidentiary difficulties associated with relying on an uncorroborated account of a telephone conversation where the person who allegedly made the communication had not testified.
103. She further submitted that the matter had been referred to the Department of Education prematurely because the internal procedures available to address the alleged conduct had not been exhausted.
104. In conclusion, Ms Kubheka submitted that the respondent had failed to establish both substantive and procedural fairness. She accordingly requested that the applicant’s dismissal be declared substantively and procedurally unfair and that the respondent be ordered to reinstate her retrospectively to the date of dismissal, without any loss of benefits.
105. In the alternative, should reinstatement not be considered appropriate, she requested that the respondent be ordered to pay the applicant compensation equivalent to the maximum of 12 months’ remuneration in terms of section 194(1) of the LRA.
ANALYSIS OF SUBMISSIONS AND ARGUMENTS
106. This matter concerns an alleged unfair dismissal arising from misconduct. In terms of section 192(2) of the Labour Relations Act, 66 of 1995, as amended (the LRA), once the existence of a dismissal has been established, the employer bears the onus of proving that the dismissal was fair. In the present matter, the existence of the dismissal is common cause. Accordingly, the respondent bears the onus of proving, on a balance of probabilities, that the dismissal was substantively and procedurally fair.
107. The applicant did not call any additional witnesses to support her case. The respondent, on the other hand, called three witnesses in support of its case. Both parties submitted documentary bundles, which I will refer to as Bundle A and Bundle R, respectively. The parties also submitted written closing arguments, which I have considered in reaching my determination.
SUBSTANTIVE FAIRNESS
108. The dispute arises from allegations of dishonesty and the solicitation and receipt of money in connection with the recruitment process for a vacant Post Level 1 position at Emdeni Secondary School during 2024. Ms Khumalo was one of the candidates who applied for the advertised position and was shortlisted for an interview.
109. It is necessary to consider the circumstances surrounding the recruitment process before evaluating the allegations against the applicant.
110. The evidence established that the SGB constituted an interview panel comprising representatives of the parent component, including the applicant, as well as other relevant role players from the school. The Principal, Mr Mashigo, and Ms Sibongile Sheedzi, the Head of Department responsible for Home Languages, also participated in the process. The applicant served as the chairperson of the interview panel in her capacity as a parent representative.
111. It was further established that the panel was responsible for the shortlisting and interviewing processes. The panel agreed that Mr Mashigo, as the principal, would contact the shortlisted candidates and inform them of the interview arrangements.
112. Mr Mashigo testified that he contacted the shortlisted candidates, including Ms Khumalo. The applicant did not materially dispute his evidence in this regard. I accordingly accept that the principal was assigned the responsibility of communicating the interview arrangements to the candidates.
113. Ms Khumalo’s evidence was that, after receiving communication from the Principal regarding the interview, she received another telephone call from an individual who initially did not identify herself. During that conversation, she was allegedly informed that candidates from KwaZulu-Natal were expected to pay R20 000,00 to secure the advertised position. The caller allegedly indicated that she could be accommodated at a reduced amount of R8 000,00.
114. Ms Khumalo testified that she informed the caller that she could only afford R6 000,00, and the parties eventually agreed on that amount. She further testified that the caller promised to provide her with the interview questions beforehand. It was during their subsequent communication that the caller identified herself as the applicant, Ms Kunene.
115. Significantly, Ms Khumalo identified the cellphone number commencing with 081 as the number used by the applicant to communicate with her. During cross-examination, the applicant conceded that the number commencing with 081 belonged to her.
116. I have considered Ms Kubheka’s argument that Ms Khumalo’s evidence regarding the alleged telephone conversations constituted hearsay evidence and should therefore be rejected. I do not agree with this submission. Ms Khumalo testified about conversations in which she was personally involved. Her evidence regarding what was communicated to her by the caller is therefore direct evidence of the conversations, rather than hearsay merely because no recordings of those conversations were produced.
117. The absence of telephone recordings is a factor to consider when assessing the weight of the evidence, but it does not, without more, render Ms Khumalo’s testimony inadmissible or unreliable. More importantly, her identification of the cellphone number used in the communication was supported by the applicant’s own concession that the number belonged to her.
118. I accordingly find that the applicant’s connection to the communication with Ms Khumalo was established on a balance of probabilities. The applicant’s denial of the alleged arrangement must be assessed against the documentary evidence, the subsequent communications and the surrounding circumstances.
119. It is further common cause that Ms Khumalo received communication from the principal regarding the outcome of the recruitment process. According to her testimony, approximately two hours after receiving communication from the principal, the applicant contacted her and reminded her to honour their agreement.
120. Ms Khumalo testified that the applicant specifically instructed her to make the payment through a cash-send facility. She subsequently sent an amount of R3 000,00 and forwarded the relevant transaction details to the applicant. She explained that she only paid half of the agreed amount at that stage because she remained sceptical about the arrangement.
121. On 6 February 2024, she paid the outstanding balance of R3 000,00, bringing the total payment to R6 000,00. She testified that she forwarded the cash-send collection details and PIN to the applicant, who subsequently sent her a voice note thanking her.
122. The applicant conceded that both cellphone numbers commencing with 081 and 069 belonged to her. She also acknowledged receiving the transaction receipts from Ms Khumalo, although she denied receiving the money.
123. I find the applicant’s explanation in this regard unpersuasive. The evidence was not merely that Ms Khumalo had sent transaction receipts to an unrelated person. The receipts and collection details were sent to cellphone numbers which the applicant herself acknowledged belonged to her. This evidence must be considered together with Ms Khumalo’s testimony regarding the prior agreement, the applicant’s alleged instructions to use the cash-send facility and the subsequent voice note thanking her.
124. The applicant’s explanation that she received only the receipts, but not the money, does not adequately account for the circumstances in which the transactions occurred. In particular, she did not provide a satisfactory explanation for receiving the cash-send details and PINs on her own cellphone numbers or for the communication that followed the transactions.
125. I have also considered the applicant’s argument that Ms Khumalo failed to explain why she forwarded the transaction receipts to her. In my view, this argument must be considered in the context of the evidence as a whole. Ms Khumalo testified that she had entered into an arrangement with the applicant and was instructed to make the payments through the cash-send facility. The forwarding of the transaction details was consistent with her version of the arrangement.
126. The applicant’s version was that she had assisted Ms Khumalo with accommodation and that the amounts in question related to security deposits. However, this explanation only emerged during the applicant’s cross-examination. It was not put to Ms Khumalo during her testimony, thereby depriving her of an opportunity to respond to that version.
127. I am mindful that the failure to put a particular version to a witness does not automatically establish that the opposing version is true. However, where a material explanation is introduced only at a later stage, and the witness against whom it is directed was not afforded an opportunity to respond, this may affect the evidentiary weight to be attached to that explanation.
128. Furthermore, the applicant’s explanation that she was merely assisting Ms Khumalo with accommodation does not satisfactorily explain the alleged agreement to pay money in connection with securing the advertised position, the timing of the payments and the subsequent communication between the parties.
129. I have also considered the evidence relating to the third allegation. Ms Khumalo testified that, on or around 22 March 2024, the applicant contacted her and requested a further amount of R4 000,00, allegedly on behalf of another person who had signed the relevant forms. According to Ms Khumalo, the applicant suggested that she could pay a reduced amount of R3 500,00 or R2 500,00 if she could not afford the full amount. Ms Khumalo eventually paid R2 000,00.
130. The applicant’s evidence did not satisfactorily address this allegation. In particular, she did not provide a convincing explanation for the further payment or the circumstances under which the transaction details were communicated between the parties.
131. I have noted that the applicant suggested that the amounts were connected to accommodation and security deposits. However, this explanation must be weighed against Ms Khumalo’s direct testimony regarding the alleged demands for money and the circumstances in which the payments were made. On the evidence before me, I find Ms Khumalo’s version more probable.
132. I further consider the evidence relating to the alleged disclosure of interview questions. Ms Khumalo testified that the applicant sent her interview questions and possible answers before the interview. She maintained that only two of the questions asked during the interview had not appeared in the material she had received.
133. Mr Mashigo corroborated the applicant’s participation in formulating the interview questions. He testified that the applicant participated actively in the process and contributed towards structuring the questions. His evidence establishes that the applicant had access to the interview questions in her capacity as a panel member.
134. However, I am mindful that Mr Mashigo did not personally witness the applicant sending the questions to Ms Khumalo. His evidence therefore corroborates the applicant’s access to and involvement in preparing the questions, but does not independently establish their subsequent disclosure.
135. Nevertheless, Ms Khumalo’s testimony that she received the questions from the applicant must be considered together with the cellphone communications, the applicant’s admitted ownership of the relevant cellphone numbers and the surrounding circumstances of the recruitment process. I find that the respondent’s evidence, considered cumulatively, supports the conclusion that the applicant disclosed confidential interview information to Ms Khumalo.
136. I have considered Ms Kubheka’s submission that Ms Khumalo was desperate to secure employment because she had been unemployed for approximately seven years. While this circumstance is relevant when assessing her credibility, it does not, in itself, render her evidence unreliable. Her testimony must be evaluated against the objective evidence and the probabilities of the case.
137. I have also considered the applicant’s submission that Ms Khumalo did not report the alleged arrangement immediately. The delay in reporting the matter is a relevant consideration. However, Ms Khumalo explained that she initially believed that the arrangement would secure her employment and only reported it after further demands for money were allegedly made. I do not consider the delay, in the circumstances of this matter, sufficient to reject her evidence.
138. The respondent was not required to produce a separate investigation report as an indispensable prerequisite to proving the allegations at arbitration. The issue before me is whether the evidence presented establishes the alleged misconduct on a balance of probabilities. The absence of an investigation report may be relevant to the overall evidentiary assessment, but it does not automatically render the dismissal substantively unfair.
139. Similarly, I have considered the applicant’s argument regarding the absence of a RICA compliance certificate. The relevant question is whether the electronic communications and transaction records relied upon by the respondent were properly authenticated and whether they may be admitted and given evidentiary weight. The mere absence of a RICA certificate does not, without further evidence establishing unlawful interception or acquisition, automatically render all the electronic evidence inadmissible.
140. I must also determine whether the applicant’s conduct, allegedly committed in her capacity as an SGB member and parent representative, had a sufficient connection to her employment as an educator to justify disciplinary action by the respondent.
141. The applicant’s argument is that the Department exceeded its statutory powers by disciplining her for conduct performed in her capacity as an SGB member. I have considered the argument and the authorities referred to by Ms Kubheka concerning the statutory governance powers of SGBs.
142. I accept that an SGB exercises statutory functions in terms of the South African Schools Act and that an educator does not cease to act in a separate governance capacity merely because he or she is employed by the Department. However, this does not necessarily mean that conduct committed in that capacity is immune from the employer’s disciplinary jurisdiction.
143. The relevant consideration is whether the alleged misconduct has a sufficient connection with the employment relationship and whether it impacts on the employee’s professional obligations, the employer’s interests or the trust relationship.
144. In the present matter, the applicant was not merely participating in an unrelated personal activity. She was serving as the chairperson of an interview panel responsible for the recruitment of an educator at a public school. The alleged solicitation and receipt of money from a candidate, together with the alleged disclosure of confidential interview questions, directly concerned the integrity of the recruitment process within the Department’s education system.
145. In my view, the conduct, if established, has a direct bearing on the integrity of the education system and the respondent’s legitimate interest in ensuring that recruitment processes are conducted fairly, transparently and without improper influence.
146. I therefore find that the applicant’s reliance on her capacity as an SGB member does not, in the circumstances of this case, absolve her of accountability under her employment relationship. The respondent had a legitimate interest in addressing conduct that potentially compromised the integrity of a recruitment process within its education system.
147. Having considered the totality of the evidence, I am satisfied that the respondent has established, on a balance of probabilities, that the applicant engaged in dishonest conduct by soliciting and receiving money in connection with the recruitment process and by improperly disclosing interview information to a candidate.
148. Such conduct is inconsistent with the standards of honesty, integrity and professional conduct expected of an educator. It further undermines public confidence in the Department’s recruitment processes and damages the trust relationship between the applicant and the respondent.
149. I accordingly find that the respondent has discharged its onus of proving substantive fairness in terms of section 192(2) of the LRA. The applicant’s dismissal was substantively fair.
PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS
150. I now turn to the question of whether the applicant’s dismissal was procedurally fair.
151. The applicant’s principal contention is that the disciplinary proceedings continued in her absence despite her submission of a medical certificate. She further argued that she was not afforded an adequate opportunity to present her case and that the respondent failed to comply with the audi alteram partem principle.
152. It is evident from the evidence that the disciplinary proceedings were subject to several postponements from September 2025 until approximately March 2026. The applicant acknowledged during cross-examination that some of the postponements were occasioned by circumstances relating to her and the availability of her union representative.
153. The applicant testified that she was booked off sick from 19 January 2026 until 17 February 2026. She further indicated that her union representative, Mr Ndlovu, was unavailable and that this contributed to her failure to attend the disciplinary proceedings.
154. I have considered the applicant’s explanation that she was not aware of the disciplinary hearing because the notice had been communicated to her union. However, she also testified that she did not attend because her union representative was unavailable. These explanations must be considered together when determining whether she was afforded a reasonable opportunity to participate in the disciplinary process.
155. I accept that an employee is entitled to a fair opportunity to respond to allegations of misconduct before a decision to dismiss is taken. However, that entitlement must be considered alongside the employee’s obligation to cooperate reasonably with the disciplinary process and to utilise the opportunities afforded to present a defence.
156. The applicant’s medical certificate covered the period from 19 January 2026 until 17 February 2026. The evidence further indicates that the disciplinary proceedings had been subject to postponements over a considerable period. The applicant’s medical condition must be distinguished from her reliance on the unavailability of her union representative as a reason for not attending.
157. I have also considered the evidence of Mr Tshabalala regarding the events of 14 May 2026. He testified that Mr Jafta attended the school to serve documents on the applicant. He further testified that, after the applicant refused to sign the documents, he was requested to intervene and encourage her to accept and sign them. The applicant nevertheless maintained that Mr Jafta should consult her union representative.
158. Mr Tshabalala’s evidence that the applicant refused to sign the documents was not materially disputed. However, he conceded that he had not read the documents and was unaware of their contents. I therefore attach limited weight to his evidence regarding the nature and purpose of those documents. His testimony is relevant primarily to the circumstances surrounding the attempted service and the applicant’s response.
159. I am mindful that an employee’s refusal to sign a document does not, in itself, establish that the employee was afforded a fair hearing. The decisive consideration remains whether the employee was properly notified of the allegations and was afforded a reasonable opportunity to respond before the decision to dismiss was taken.
160. In the present matter, however, the evidence regarding the history of postponements, the applicant’s acknowledgment that her union representative was unavailable, and the subsequent attempts to engage with her must be considered cumulatively.
161. I am not persuaded that the applicant’s reliance on the audi alteram partem principle, without adequately accounting for her own failure to participate in the disciplinary process, is sufficient to establish procedural unfairness.
162. The audi alteram partem principle requires that an employee be afforded a fair opportunity to be heard. It does not require an employer to postpone disciplinary proceedings indefinitely where reasonable opportunities have already been afforded and the employee fails to utilise them without sufficient justification.
163. Having considered the evidence, I find that the applicant was afforded opportunities to participate in the disciplinary process. Her failure to utilise those opportunities, particularly after the period covered by her medical certificate had expired, cannot automatically be attributed to procedural unfairness on the part of the respondent.
164. I accordingly find that the respondent has discharged its onus of proving that the disciplinary process was procedurally fair.
AWARD
165. Having considered the totality of the evidence, the parties’ respective submissions and the applicable legal principles, I find that the respondent has established, on a balance of probabilities, that the applicant’s dismissal was both substantively and procedurally fair.
166. The applicant’s conduct undermined the integrity of the recruitment process and was incompatible with the standards of honesty and professional conduct expected of an educator. Furthermore, I am not satisfied that the applicant has established that the respondent denied her a reasonable opportunity to present her case during the disciplinary process.
167. In the premises, the applicant’s claim of unfair dismissal cannot succeed.
168. This matter is dismissed.
P. Maitsha
ELRC Panelist
20 November 2026

